Jump to content

Nimbarka

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Nimbarkacharya)

Nimbarka
An icon of Nimbarkacharya at Kathiababa Ashram, Vrindavan
Personal life
BornNiyamananda
Not recognized as a date. Years must have 4 digits (use leading zeros for years < 1000).
Pratiṣṭḥāna, India[1]
Died1200 (aged 69–70)
Vrindavan, India
Parents
  • Jagannath and Sarasvati
  • or
  • Aruna Rishi and Jayanti devi[2]
HonorsJagadguru, Pravakta acharya
Religious life
ReligionHinduism
OrderVedanta
Founder ofNimbarka Sampradaya
PhilosophyDvaitadvaita Vedanta
Religious career
Disciples

Nimbarka, also known as Nimbarkacharya, Nimbaditya or Niyamananda, was a Bhagavata philosopher, theologian and the chief proponent of the theology of Dvaitādvaita (dvaita–advaita) or dualistic–non-dualistic sometimes known as Svābhāvika bhedābheda. He is associated with the theological elevation of Vāsudeva Krishna, and is regarded as the founder of the Nimbarka Sampradaya.[4][5][6]

The dating of Nimbarka is disputed. Many historians place him in the 12th or 13th century,[7] but this dating has been questioned, suggesting that he lived somewhat earlier than Shankaracharya, in the 6th or 7th century CE.[1] Born in Southern India in a Telugu Brahmin family,[6] he spent most of his life in Mathura, Uttar Pradesh. He is sometimes identified with another philosopher named Bhaskara,[8] but this is considered to be a misconception due to the differences between the spiritual views of the two saints.[3][9]

Etymology and epithets

[edit]

The word 'Nimbārka' (निंबार्क) is derived from two Sanskrit words — nimba (निम्ब) and arka (अर्क). It is believed that Nimbarka was given the name 'Niyamananda' at his birth. According to a folk tale, Niyamananda achieve the name Nimbarka because he trapped some rays of sunlight (arka) in the leaves of Neem (nimba). Also according to a traditional accoount, the young Niyamananda was hosting an ascetic gues who would not eat after sunset. As dusk fell, he placed Vishnu's Sudarshana Chakra on a neem (nimba) tree, where it shone like the sun (arka), so that the guest could eat; in Swami Sivananda's telling the guest was Brahma in disguise, who then gave him the name Nimbarka.[10] Other tellings describe the guest as a ''daṇḍī'' (a staff-bearing renunciate) and have the sun god himself wait on the neem tree.[11] He was also referred as Nimbaditya by his followers.[12] Sometimes Bhaskara is also considered his epithet because of the identification of Nimbarka with the philosopher Bhaskara.[13]

Datings

[edit]

Nimbarka's traditional followers believe that he appeared in 3096 BCE, but this dating is controversial as historians believe that he lived between 7th and 11th century CE.[12] According to Roma Bose, Nimbarka lived in the 13th century, on the presupposition that Nimbarkacharya was the author of the work Madhvamukhamardana.[14] Meanwhile, Vijay Ramnarace concluded that the work Madhvamukhamardana has been wrongly attributed to Nimbarkacharya.[15] This view is also supported by traditional scholars.[16] Bhandarkar places Nimbārka after Rāmānuja, suggesting 1162 CE as the approximate date of his demise,[17] though he acknowledged that this estimation is highly speculative.[18] S.N. Dasgupta, on the other hand, dates Nimbārka to the mid-14th century.[19] Dasgupta bases this dating on the absence of Nimbārka's mention in the Sarvadarśanasaṅgraha, a doxography by 14th-century author Mādhava Vidyāraṇya.[20] However, none of the Bhedābhedins—whether Bhartṛprapañca, Nimbārka, Bhāskara, or Yādavaprakāśa—are referenced in the Sarvadarśanasaṅgraha.[21] While S. A. A. Rizvi assigns a date of c.1130–1200 CE.[22]

According to Satyanand, Bose's dating of the 13th century is an erroneous attribution.[23] Malkovsky, following Satyanand, notes that in Bhandarkar's own work it is clearly stated that his dating of Nimbarka was an approximation based on an extremely flimsy calculation; yet most scholars chose to honour his suggested date, even until modern times.[5] According to Malkovsky, Satyanand has convincingly demonstrated that Nimbarka and his immediate disciple Srinivasacharya flourished well before Ramanuja (1017–1137 CE), arguing that Srinivasacharya was a contemporary, or just after Sankaracarya (early 8th century).[5] According to Ramnarace, summarising the available research, Nimbarka must be dated in the 7th century CE.[24]

Biography

[edit]

Little is known about Nimbarka's life. He is said to have been born into a Telugu Brahmin family[6] on the 3rd bright half of the month Vaisakha. His parents were Jagannath, a Bhagavata saint, and his wife Sarasvati, who lived in Pratiṣṭḥāna, which is in present-day Paithan, Maharashtra.[1][25] However, some other versions suggest that the name of his parents were Aruna Rishi and Jayanti Devi,[2] who lived in a place near the river Godavari, which may be in Maharashtra. Nimbarka's followers believe him as the incarnation of Vishnu's weapon, Sudarshana Chakra.[12][26]

It is believed that Nimbarka was given the name Niyamananda at his birth, but sometimes Bhaskara is considered as his birth name.[13][27] During Nimbarka's early years, it is described that his family moved to Vrindavan, but there is no historical recorded account.[28]

Works of Nimbarka

[edit]

Vedanta Parijata Saurabha

[edit]

The Vedānta Pārijāta Saurabha composed by Nimbārka is extremely concise and does not refute the views of others. According to the Sanskrit scholar Upadhyay, this form of commentary undoubtedly indicates it's antiquity.[29] The Vedānta Pārijāta Saurabha represents an earlier style of Brahmasūtra commentary in the manner of the authors that preceded Śaṅkara.[30] It supports the bhedābheda school of Vedānta,[29] which advocates the view of a relationship of simultaneous unity and diversity between Brahman, the individual soul (jīva) and the universe (jagat).[31] Nimbarka writes that performing karma is not a means to liberation. He takes knowledge, attained through devotion, as the means to liberation.[32]

Vedānta Pārijāta Saurabha is further commented by Srinivasacharya in his Vedanta kaustubha[33][34]

Vedanta kamadhenu dashashloki

[edit]

The dashashloki is very simple, suited to a devotee who is not concerned with logical theories and arguments, but seeks simple and immediate truth .[35][32]

The Vedānta kāmadhenu Daśaślokī have been extensively commented upon by several scholars. Among them, the three primary commentaries[36] are:

Mantrarahasyaṣoḍaśī and Prapannakalpavallī

[edit]

Mantrarahasyaṣoḍaśī is a work consisting of 18 verses, with the first 16 dedicated to exposition of the revered 18-syllable Gopāla Mantra, a central element of the Nimbārka tradition. Sundara bhaṭṭācharya has authored a commentary on this work titled Mantrārtharahasya.[41]

The Prapannakalpavallī explains the mukunda śaraṇāgati mantra. On this, Sundara bhaṭṭācharya has written an extensive commentary titled Prapannasuratarumañjarī.[41]

Not a Radhakrishna worshipper

[edit]

The present-day followers of Nimbarka are worshippers of Radhakrishna. There is a general belief that Nimbarka himself was a worshipper of Radhakrishna and composed a few prayer stanzas, or stotras, in honour of Radha and Krishna.[42] Contrary to these traditional beliefs, it must be pointed out that there is no mention of either Radha or Radhakrishna in the entire Saurabha. The goddess whom he associates with Purushottama is Rama, who is identified with Lakshmi by Amara Simha in his Amarakosha, a work dating to the 6th century AD.[43][44] The mere absence of any mention of Radha or Radhakrishna throughout the Saurabha goes a long way towards undermining the claim that Nimbarka was the propagator of the Radhakrishna cult. As seen in the Saurabha itself, his Ishtadevata is Ramakanta. He could easily have substituted the word Radha for Rama had he been a worshipper of Radhakrishna, since the passage in which the name occurs is in prose and, as such, does not require any change for the sake of metre. Furthermore, it must be pointed out that there is a contradiction within the tradition of the Nimbarka school itself, which holds that Nimbarka lived at the end of the Dvapara Yuga[45] and was a propagator of the Radhakrishna cult. However, all the available evidence suggests that Radha appeared on the religious scene only after the 10th century AD.[46][47]

Philosophy

[edit]

Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita philosophy emphasizes a dualistic non-dualism where the soul is both distinct and non-distinct from God. His teachings emphasize devotion to Krishna and Ramā.[48]

Brahman

[edit]

According to Nimbarka, the ultimate reality or Brahman is Krishna, recognized by various names such as Purushottama, Hari, Vāsudeva and Bhagavan. He is accompanied by Ramā.[49] Brahman, as described by Nimbarka, is flawless, possessing auspicious qualities and transcending the influence of karma, and with attributes such as knowledge, power, and compassion; Brahman is also both the material and efficient cause of creation, likened to a sovereign emperor engaging in playful activities without specific outcomes in mind.[50]

Jiva

[edit]

Nimbarka considered the jiva to possess inherent knowledge (jnana), which distinguishes it from non-sentient elements such as the body, sense organs, and mind. This inherent knowledge permeates every state of the jiva, including waking, dreaming, and deep sleep. Nimbarka explains that the jiva is both knowledge and knower, likening their relationship to that of a gem and its radiance, where they are distinct yet inseparable, existing in a relationship of substrate and attribute.[51] Nimbarka writes that there are an infinite number of jivas.[52] He argues that if there were only one jiva, then if one person slept, everyone should sleep, and if one person were happy or sad, everyone would feel the same.[53]

Relationship between Brahman and Jiva

[edit]

Nimbarka's philosophy distinctively outlines the differences between jiva and Brahman by emphasizing their intrinsic relationship as cause and effect, part and whole. Brahman is portrayed as the ultimate cause and the whole, whereas jiva, the individual soul that experiences pleasure and pain, is seen as an effect or a transformation of Brahman. This relationship is analogous to clay transforming into pottery or a tree bearing leaves and fruits, showing differences between the source material and its derivatives. Using scriptural references, Nimbarka asserted that jiva, as a part of the omnipotent Brahman, lacks independence and fullness of power.[54]

Relation to other Vedanta schools

[edit]

Like Nimbarka, acharyas of other Vedanta schools also accept the concepts of difference and non-difference between Jiva and Brahman as real, but they explain and reconcile these ideas in various ways:[55]

  • Nimbarka asserts that the relationship of both difference and non-difference between Jiva and Brahman is natural (svabhavika) and fully compatible, meaning these aspects coexist without conflict.
  • Ramanuja and Srikantha explain the relationship using the analogy of the soul and body (sariri-sarira), where non-difference is principal and difference is subordinate.
  • Chaitanya Mahaprabhu considers the concepts of difference and non-difference to be inconceivable (acintya), implying that human understanding is limited in fully grasping how both can be true simultaneously.

From a comparative perspective, Martine Chifflot situates Nimbarka's bhedābheda within the broader spectrum of Vedāntic schools by contrasting the dualist-non-dualist position with the strictly non-dualist Advaita of Śaṅkara. Where Advaita dissolves all ontological difference between jīva and Brahman, Nimbarka's svābhāvika bhedābheda preserves their simultaneous distinction and identity as an irreducible natural relation.[56]

Legacy

[edit]

Vijay Ramnarace doubts that Nimbarka's own works present the deification of Radha-Krishna as an innovation, but that the early tradition reserved the theological identification of Brahman for the most eligible initiates, and that the doctrine was rationalised by Purushottama, third successor to Nimbarka, in a way that reduced its impact in the wider Vaishnava context.[57] He proposes that a renaissance of Radha–Krishna devotion was instigated in 15th-century Vraja by Keśava Kāśmīrin, Śrībhaṭṭa and Harivyāsa Deva, who influenced contemporary and later sects.[57]

As per Gérard Colas, Keshava Kashmiri is the first Nimbarka acharya whose association with Braj is certain, and his ritual treatise the ''Kramadipika'' influenced Chaitanyaite authors. [58] The Gaudiya tradition, following Krishnadas Kaviraja's ''Chaitanya Charitamrita'', holds that Keshava Kashmiri met the young Chaitanya in a contest of Sanskrit learning.[59]

References

[edit]
  1. 1 2 3 Ramnarace 2014, p. 113.
  2. 1 2 Saraswati 1997, p. 174.
  3. 1 2 Dalal 2010, p. 129.
  4. ↑ Satyanand 1997.
  5. 1 2 3 Malkovsky 2001, p. 118.
  6. 1 2 3 "Nimbarka | Indian philosopher | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 14 January 2022.
  7. ↑ Jones & Ryan 2006, p. 312.
  8. ↑ Hoiberg 2000.
  9. ↑ Raju 2013, p. 158.
  10. ↑ Sivananda n.d.
  11. ↑ Bhaktivedanta Tirtha n.d.
  12. 1 2 3 Mukundananda 2014.
  13. 1 2 Ph.D 2016, p. 194.
  14. ↑ Bose 2004.
  15. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, p. 76,77.
  16. ↑ SrI Purushottamacharya ji (1950). Vedanta Ratna Manjusha With Kunchika Part 2. pp. 6, 7.
  17. ↑ Bhandarkar 1987, p. 62,63.
  18. 1 2 Bhandarkar 1987, p. 63.
  19. ↑ Dasgupta 1988, p. 400,401.
  20. ↑ Dasgupta 1988, p. 400.
  21. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, p. 79,80.
  22. ↑ Saiyed A A Rizvi- A history of Sufism in India, Vol.1 (Munshi Ram Manoharlal Publishing Private Limited: 1978), page 355
  23. ↑ Satyanand, J. Nimbārka: A Pre-Śaṅkara Vedāntin and his philosophy, Varanasi, 1997
  24. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, p. 180.
  25. ↑ Agrawal 2013, p. 62.
  26. ↑ Bhandarkar 1987.
  27. ↑ Pandey 2008.
  28. ↑ Dalal 2010.
  29. 1 2 Upadhyay 1978, p. 300.
  30. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, p. 100.
  31. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, p. 81.
  32. 1 2 Ramnarace 2014, p. 189.
  33. ↑ Agrawal 2013, p. 97.
  34. ↑ Dasgupta 1988, p. 402.
  35. ↑ Bose 2004, p. 920.
  36. 1 2 3 4 Dasgupta 1988, p. 403.
  37. 1 2 Agrawal 2013, p. 269.
  38. ↑ Naganath, Dr S. Srikanta Sastri, English Translation by S. (11 May 2022). Indian Culture: A Compendium of Indian History, Culture and Heritage. Notion Press. ISBN 978-1-63806-511-1.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  39. ↑ Upadhyay 1978, p. 305.
  40. ↑ Dasgupta 1988, p. 399.
  41. 1 2 Upadhyay 1978, p. 301.
  42. ↑ Bose 2004, p. 917–921.
  43. ↑ Dhall, Upendra Nath (1978). Goddess Laksmi Origin and Development. Delhi: Oriental Publishers & Distributors. p. 107.
  44. ↑ Keith, A.B. (1921). Karma Mīmāṁsā. Calcutta. p. 413.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  45. ↑ Ācāryacaritam, pp. 34-35, 42-48.
  46. ↑ Banerjea, J.N. (1974). The Development of Hindu Iconography (3rd ed.). Delhi: M. Manoharlal. p. 422. points out that in archaeological investigations only reliefs belonging to late medieval and modern periods illustrate the cowherd (Gopāla) Krṣṇa's dalliance with the cowherdesses (Gopis), the chief among whom was Rādhā.
  47. ↑ Satyanand 1997, p. 30-31.
  48. ↑ Dalal 2010b.
  49. ↑ Bose 2004, p. 108.
  50. ↑ Agrawal 1957, p. 110-111.
  51. ↑ Agrawal 1957, p. 100-101.
  52. ↑ Ramnarace 2014, pp. 189–190.
  53. ↑ Agraeal, mohan Madan (1957). The Philosophy Of Nimbarka. p. 107.
  54. ↑ Agrawal 1957, p. 81-83.
  55. ↑ Agrawal 1957, p. 135.
  56. ↑ Chifflot, Martine (2022). "La libération selon le Yoga et le Védānta". L'Enseignement philosophique. 72 (5): 35–46. doi:10.3917/eph.725.0035. Retrieved 4 May 2026.
  57. 1 2 Ramnarace 2015.
  58. ↑ Colas 2003, p. 253.
  59. ↑ K. R. K. Swami 2010.

Bibliography

[edit]