Jump to content

Advaita Vedanta

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Adi Shankara, the most prominent exponent of Advaita Vedānta tradition.
"I am other than name, form and action.
My nature is ever free!
I am Self, the supreme unconditioned Brahman.
I am pure Awareness, always non-dual."
Adi Shankara, Upadesasahasri 11.7[1]

Advaita Vedanta (/ʌdˈvaɪtə vɛˈdɑːntə/; Sanskrit: अद्वैतवेदान्तः, IAST: Advaita Vedānta) is a Hindu tradition of Vedanta, a Brahmanical tradition of textual exegesis and philosophy; and a monastic institutional tradition nominally related to the Daśanāmi Sampradaya and propagated by the Smarta tradition. Its core tenet is that jivatman, the individual experiencing self, is ultimately pure awareness mistakenly identified with the body and its senses[2] and with thought-constructs,[3] and non-different from Ātman-Brahman or sat, the highest Self or Real.[4][5][6][note 1] The term Advaita (अद्वैत) literally means "not-two"[7][8] or "one without a second",[8] which means that only Brahman, 'the one', is ultimately real while prapanca, 'the second', 'the world' or the multiplicity of thought-constructs, is not fully real.[9] It is commonly rendered as "nonduality",[10][11] and popularly interpreted as meaning that Atman is non-different from Brahman, and often equated with monism.[note 2]

Advaita Vedanta is a Hindu sādhanā, a path of spiritual discipline and experience.[note 3] It states that moksha ('liberation', freedom)[12][13] is attained when knowledge of Brahman is attained, recognising the illusoriness of the phenomenal world and disidentifying from body-mind and the notion of 'doership',[note 4] acquiring vidyā (knowledge)[14] of one's true identity as Atman-Brahman,[1][15][16][17] self-luminous (svayam prakāśa)[note 5] awareness or Witness-consciousness.[18][note 6] This knowledge is revealed through Upanishadic statements such as tat tvam asi, "that['s how] you are", which destroy the ignorance (avidyā) regarding one's true identity by revealing that (jiv)Ātman is non-different from immortal[note 7] Brahman.[note 1]

The Advaita vedanta tradition modifies the Samkhya-dualism between Purusha (pure awareness or consciousness) and Prakriti ('nature', which includes matter but also cognition and emotion) as the two equal basic principles of existence.[19][20] It proposes instead that Atman-Brahman (awareness, purusha) alone is ultimately real and, though unchanging,[21] is the cause and origin of the transient phenomenal world (prakriti). In this view, the jivatman or individual self is a mere reflection or limitation of singular Ātman in a multitude of apparent individual bodies.[22] It regards the material world as an illusory appearance (maya) or "an unreal manifestation (vivarta) of Brahman",[23] the latter as proposed by the 13th-century scholar Prakasatman of the Vivarana school.[24]

Advaita Vedanta is often presented as an elite scholarly tradition belonging to the orthodox Hindu Vedānta[note 8] tradition, emphasising scholarly works written in Sanskrit;[25] as such, it is an "iconic representation of Hindu religion and culture."[26] Yet contemporary Advaita Vedanta is yogic Advaita, a medieval and modern syncretic tradition incorporating Yoga and other traditions, and producing works in vernacular.[25] The earliest Advaita writings are the Sannyasa Upanishads (first centuries CE), the Vākyapadīya, written by Bhartṛhari (second half 5th century,[27]) and the Māndūkya-kārikā written by Gauḍapāda (7th century).[28] Gaudapada adapted philosophical concepts from Buddhism, giving them a Vedantic basis and interpretation.[29] The Buddhist concepts were further Vedanticised by Adi Shankara (8th c. CE), who is generally regarded as the most prominent exponent of the Advaita Vedānta tradition,[30][31][32][33] though some of the most prominent Advaita-propositions come from other Advaitins, and his early influence has been questioned.[34][35][note 9] Adi Shankara emphasized that, since Brahman is ever-present, Brahman-knowledge is immediate and requires no 'action' or 'doership', that is, striving (to attain) and effort.[36][37][38] Nevertheless, the Advaita tradition, as represented by Mandana Misra and the Bhamati school, also prescribes elaborate preparatory practice, including contemplation of mahavakyas,[37][39][40][41][note 9] presenting a tension between sudden and gradual approaches which is also recognized in other spiritual disciplines and traditions.[37][42][note 10]

Shankaracharya's prominence as the exemplary defender of traditional Hindu-values and spirituality started to take shape only centuries later, in the 14th century, with the ascent of Sringeri matha and its jagadguru Vidyaranya (Madhava, 14th cent.) in the Vijayanagara Empire,[note 11] While Adi Shankara did not embrace Yoga,[43] the Advaita-tradition by then had accepted yogic samadhi as a means to still the mind and attain knowledge, explicitly incorporating elements from the yogic tradition and texts like the Yoga Vasistha and the Bhagavata Purana,[44] culminating in Swami Vivekananda's full embrace and propagation of Yogic samadhi as an Advaita means of knowledge and liberation.[45][46] In the 19th century, due to the influence of Vidyaranya's Sarvadarśanasaṅgraha,[47] the importance of Advaita Vedānta was overemphasized by Western scholarship,[48] and Advaita Vedānta came to be regarded as the paradigmatic example of Hindu spirituality, despite the numerical dominance of theistic Bhakti-oriented religiosity.[49][50][48][note 9] In modern times, Advaita views appear in various Neo-Vedānta movements.[51]

Etymology and nomenclature

[edit]

Etymology

[edit]

The word Advaita is a composite of two Sanskrit words:

  • Prefix "a-" (अ), meaning "non-"
  • "Dvaita" (द्वैत), which means 'duality' or 'dualism'.[web 1]

Advaita is often translated as "non-duality", but a more apt translation is "non-secondness".[4] Fabian Volker, following Paul Hacker explains that dvaita does not mean "duality", but "the state in which a second is present", synonymous with prapanca, "conceptual proliferation", and with jagat, "the world". Advaita thus means that only Brahman, 'the one', is ultimately real, while the world with its multiplicity, 'the second', is not fully real.[9] As Gaudapada states, when the unreal is taken as real, people grasp to the unreal, which is samsara. By realizing one's true identity as Brahman, there is no more grasping, and the mind comes to rest.[52]

In a popular sense, advaita is often expressed as the famous diction that Atman is Brahman, meaning that jivatman, the individual experiencing self, is ultimately pure awareness mistakenly identified with body and the senses,[2] and non-different ("na aparah") from Ātman/Brahman, the highest Self or Reality;[4][5][6][note 1]; the knowledge of this true identity is liberating.

The word Vedānta is a composition of two Sanskrit words: The word Veda refers to the whole corpus of vedic texts, and the word "anta" means 'end'. From this, one meaning of Vedānta is "the end of the Vedas" or "the ultimate knowledge of the Vedas". As all the vedas are divided into four parts i.e. Samhita, Brahmana, Aranyaka and Upanishads, Upanishads are the ultimate and final part of vedas,[53][54] Vedanta is called as Upanishads.[55] Veda can also mean "knowledge" in general, so Vedānta can be taken to mean "the end, conclusion or finality of knowledge". Vedānta is one of six orthodox schools of Hindu philosophy.

Advaita Vedanta

[edit]

While "a preferred terminology" for Upanisadic philosophy "in the early periods, before the time of Shankara" was Puruṣavāda,[56][note 12] the Advaita Vedānta school has historically been referred to by various names, such as Advaita-vada (speaker of Advaita), Abheda-darshana (view of non-difference), Dvaita-vada-pratisedha (denial of dual distinctions), and Kevala-dvaita (non-dualism of the isolated).[57] It is also called māyāvāda by Vaishnava opponents, akin to Madhyamaka Buddhism, due to their insistence that phenomena ultimately lack an inherent essence or reality.[58][59][60][61]

"Advaita" (अद्वैत) is from Sanskrit roots a, not; dvaita, "customarily translated as dual".[9] As Advaita, it is usually translated as "not-two"[7][8] or "one without a second",[8] and most commonly as "nondualism", "nonduality" or "nondual", invoking the notion of a dichotomy. Fabian Volker, following Paul Hacker explains that dvaita does not mean "duality", but "the state in which a second is present", the second here being synonymous with prapanca, "conceptual proliferation", and with jagat, "the world". Advaita thus means that only Brahman, 'the one', is ultimately real, while the phenomenal world, or the conceptual multiplicity, 'the second', is not fully real.[9] The term thus does not emphasize two instances, but the notion that the second instance is not fully real, and advaita is better translated as "that which has no second beside it" instead of "nonduality", denying multiplicity and the proliferation of concepts "that tend to obscure the true state of affairs."[9][note 13]

According to Richard King, a professor of Buddhist and Asian studies, the term Advaita first occurs in a recognizably Vedantic context in the prose of Mandukya Upanishad.[57] According to Frits Staal, a professor of philosophy specializing in Sanskrit and Vedic studies, the word Advaita itself is from the Vedic era, and the Vedic sage Yajnavalkya (8th or 7th-century BCE[63][64]) is credited to be the one who coined it.[65] Stephen Phillips, a professor of philosophy and Asian studies, translates the Advaita containing verse excerpt in Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, as "An ocean, a single seer without duality becomes he whose world is Brahman."[note 15]

Advaita tradition

[edit]

While the term "Advaita Vedanta" in a strict sense may refer to the scholastic tradition of textual exegesis established by Shankara and the monastic institutions, "advaita" in a broader sense may refer to a broad current of advaitic thought, which incorporates advaitic elements with yogic thought and practice and other strands of Indian religiosity, such as Kashmir Shaivism and the Nath tradition.[67] The first connotation has also been called "Classical Advaita"[33][68] and "doctrinal Advaita",[69] and its presentation as such is due to mediaeval doxographies,[46] the influence of Orientalist Indologists like Paul Deussen,[70] and the Indian response to colonial influences, dubbed neo-Vedanta by Paul Hacker, who regarded it as a deviation from "traditional" Advaita Vedanta.[33] Yet, post-Shankara Advaita Vedanta incorporated yogic elements, such as the Yoga Vasistha, and influenced other Indian traditions, and neo-Vedanta is based on this broader strand of Indian thought.[33] This broader current of thought and practice has also been called "greater Advaita Vedanta",[25] "vernacular advaita",[33] and "experiential Advaita".[69] It is this broader advaitic tradition which is commonly presented as "Advaita Vedanta", though the term "advaitic" may be more apt.[33][note 16]

Monism

[edit]

The nondualism of Advaita Vedānta is often regarded as an idealist monism.[note 2] According to King, Advaita Vedānta developed "to its ultimate extreme" the monistic ideas already present in the Upanishads.[note 17] In contrast, states Milne, it is misleading to call Advaita Vedānta "monistic", since this confuses the "negation of difference" with "conflation into one".[71] Advaita is a negative term (a-dvaita), states Milne, which denotes the "negation of a difference", between subject and object, or between perceiver and perceived.[71]

According to Deutsch, Advaita Vedānta teaches monistic oneness, however without the multiplicity premise of alternate monism theories.[72] According to Jacqueline Suthren Hirst, Adi Shankara positively emphasizes "oneness" premise in his Brahma-sutra Bhasya 2.1.20, attributing it to all the Upanishads.[73]

Nicholson states Advaita Vedānta contains realistic strands of thought, both in its oldest origins and in Shankara's writings.[74]

Soteriology: moksha – liberating knowledge of Brahman

[edit]

Knowledge is liberating

[edit]
Ramana Maharshi, the Indian sage who is widely regarded as a Jivanmukta

The soteriological goal, in Advaita, is to gain self-knowledge as being in essence (Atman), awareness or witness-consciousness, and complete understanding of the real identity of jivan-ātman as Brahman.[1] This is stated by Shankara as follows:[1]

I am other than name, form and action.
My nature is ever free!
I am Self, the supreme unconditioned Brahman.
I am pure Awareness, always non-dual.

— Adi Shankara, Upadesasahasri 11.7[75], [note 18]

Correct knowledge of Atman and Brahman is the attainment of Brahman, immortality,[76] and moksha, liberation from suffering[note 19] and samsara, the cycle of rebirth.[1]

This Self is not a personal self, but the knowledge that everything is Brahman,[77][78][note 20] that "the self is the self of all, the knower of self sees the self in all beings and all beings in the self."[79]

According to Advaita Vedānta, liberation can be achieved while living, and is called Jivanmukti.[80][81][note 21] in contrast to Videhamukti (moksha from samsara after death) in theistic sub-schools of Vedānta.[82][better source needed]

Attaining vidyā (knowledge)

[edit]

Advaita Vedānta regards the liberated state of being Atman-Brahman as one's true identity and inherent to being human. According to Shankara and the Vivarana-school, no human action can 'produce' this liberated state, as it is what one already is.[37] As Swami Vivekananda stated:

The Vedas cannot show you Brahman, you are That already. They can only help to take away the veil that hides truth from our eyes. The cessation of ignorance can only come when I know that God and I are one; in other words, identify yourself with Atman, not with human limitations. The idea that we are bound is only an illusion [Maya]. Freedom is inseparable from the nature of the Atman. This is ever pure, ever perfect, ever unchangeable.

— Adi Shankara's commentary on Fourth Vyasa Sutra, Swami Vivekananda[83]

According to Shankara, taking a subitist position,[84] moksha is attained at once when the mahavakyas, articulating the identity of Atman and Brahman, are understood.[85][38][note 22]

Yet, the Advaita-tradition also emphasizes human effort, a path of Jnana Yoga with a progression of study and training to realize one's true identity as Atman-Brahman and attain moksha.[37][39][40] According to the contemporary Advaita tradition, knowledge of Atman-Brahman is obtained gradually, by svādhyāya, study of the self and of the Vedic texts, which consists of four stages of samanyasa: virāga ('renunciation'), sravana ('listening to the teachings of the sages'), manana ('reflection on the teachings') and nididhyāsana, introspection and profound and repeated meditation on the mahavakyas, selected Upanishadic statements such as tat tvam asi ('that art thou' or 'you are That') which are taken literal, and form the srutic evidence for the identity of jivanatman and Atman-Brahman.[86][87][web 4] This meditation negates the misconceptions, false knowledge, and false ego-identity, rooted in maya, which obfuscate the ultimate truth of the oneness of Brahman, and one's true identity as Atman-Brahman.[88] This culminates in what Adi Shankara refers to as anubhava, immediate intuition, a direct awareness which is construction-free, and not construction-filled. It is not an awareness of Brahman, but instead an awareness that is Brahman.[89] Although the threefold practice is broadly accepted in the Advaita tradition, and affirmed by Mandana Misra,[90] it is at odds with Shankara,[91] who took a subitist position.[84]

Sruti (scriptures), proper reasoning and meditation are the main sources of knowledge (vidya) for the Advaita Vedānta tradition.[41][92][93] It teaches that correct knowledge of Atman and Brahman is achievable by svādhyāya,[94] study of the self and of the Vedic texts, and three stages of practice: sravana (perception, hearing), manana (thinking) and nididhyasana (meditation),[41] a three-step methodology that is rooted in the teachings of chapter 4 of the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad.[95][96]

According to critics of neo-Advaita, which also emphasizes direct insight, traditional Advaita Vedanta entails more than self-inquiry or bare insight into one's real nature, but also includes self-restraint, textual studies and ethical perfection. It is described in classical Advaita books like Shankara's Upadesasahasri[97] and the Vivekachudamani, which is also attributed to Shankara.

Preparation: the fourfold qualities

[edit]

The Advaita student has to develop the fourfold qualities,[98] or behavioral qualifications (Samanyasa, Sampattis, sādhana-catustaya):[99][100][86][note 23] A student in Advaita Vedānta tradition is required to develop these four qualities:

  1. Nityānitya vastu viveka (नित्यानित्यवस्तुविवेकः) – Viveka is the ability to correctly discriminate between the real and eternal (nitya) and the substance that is apparently real, illusory, changing and transitory (anitya).[99][86]
  2. Ihāmutrārtha phala bhoga virāga (इहाऽमुत्रार्थफलभोगविरागः) – The renunciation (virāga) of all desires of the mind (bhoga) for sense pleasures, in this world (iha) and other worlds. Willing to give up everything that is an obstacle to the pursuit of truth and self-knowledge.[86][101]
  3. Śamādi ṣatka sampatti (शमादिषट्कसम्पत्तिः) – the sixfold virtues or qualities:
    1. Śama – mental tranquility, ability to focus the mind.[86][101]
    2. Dama – self-restraint,[note 24] the virtue of temperance.[86][101] restraining the senses.
    3. Uparati – dispassion, lack of desire for worldly pleasures, ability to be quiet and disassociated from everything;[86] discontinuation of all religious duties and ceremonies[101]
    4. Titikṣa – endurance, perseverance, putting up with pairs of opposites (like heat and cold, pleasure and pain), ability to be patient during demanding circumstances[86][101]
    5. Śraddhā – having faith in teacher and the Sruti scriptural texts[86]
    6. Samādhāna – contentedness, satisfaction of mind in all conditions, attention, intentness of mind[86][101]
  4. Mumukṣutva (मुमुक्षुत्वम्) – An intense longing for freedom, liberation and wisdom, driven to the quest of knowledge and understanding. Having moksha as the primary goal of life[86][98]

The threefold practice: sravana (hearing), manana (thinking) and nididhyasana (meditation)

[edit]

The Advaita tradition teaches that correct knowledge, which destroys avidya, psychological and perceptual errors related to Atman and Brahman,[16] is obtained in jnanayoga through three stages of practice,[100] sravana (hearing), manana (thinking) and nididhyasana (meditation).[41] This three-step methodology is rooted in the teachings of chapter 4 of the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad:[95][96]

  • Sravana, which literally means hearing. The student listens and discusses the ideas, concepts, questions and answers.[41][95] of the sages on the Upanishads and Advaita Vedānta, studying the Vedantic texts, such as the Brahma Sutras, aided by discussions with the guru (teacher, counsellor).[99][105][41]
  • Manana refers to thinking on these discussions and contemplating over the various ideas based on svadhyaya and sravana.[95][105][106] It is the stage of reflection on the teachings;[95][105]
  • Nididhyāsana, the stage of meditation and introspection.[86][web 4] This stage of practice aims at realization and consequent conviction of the truths, non-duality and a state where there is a fusion of thought and action, knowing and being.[107][95]

Although the threefold practice is broadly accepted in the Advaita tradition, Shankara's works show an ambivalence toward it: while accepting its authenticity and merits, as it is based in the scriptures, he also takes a subitist position,[84] arguing that moksha is attained at once when the mahavakyas, articulating the identity of Atman and Brahman, are understood.[85][38][note 22] According to Rambachan, "it is not possible to reconcile Sankara's views with this seemingly well-ordered system."[91]

Mandana Misra, on the other hand, explicitly affirms the threefold practice as the means to acquire knowledge of Brahman, referring to meditation as dhyana.[108] He states that these practices, though conceptual, 'can eliminate both ignorance and coneptuality at the same time, leaving only the "pure, transparent nature" of self-awareness'.[109]

Bilimoria states that these three stages of Advaita practice can be viewed as sadhana practice that unifies Yoga and Karma ("action", referring here to ritual) ideas, and was most likely derived from these older traditions.[110][105]

Guru

[edit]

Advaita Vedānta school has traditionally had a high reverence for a Guru (teacher), and recommends that a competent Guru be sought in one's pursuit of spirituality, though this is not mandatory.[111] Reading of Vedic literature and reflection is the most essential practice.[111] Adi Shankara, states Comans, regularly employed compound words "such as Sastracaryopadesa (instruction by way of the scriptures and the teacher) and Vedāntacaryopadesa (instruction by way of the Upanishads and the teacher) to emphasize the importance of Guru".[111] According to Comans, this reflects the Advaita tradition which holds a competent teacher as important and essential to gaining correct knowledge, freeing oneself from false knowledge, and to self-realization.[112] Nevertheless, in the Bhamati-school the guru has a less essential role, as he can explain the teachings, but the student has to venture its further study.[113]

In his commentary on the Mundaka Upanishad, Shankara states that a guru must be approached with sacrificial wood (samid) in hand in order to acquire knowledge of Brahman (para vidya). Shankara expands that such a guru should have virtues such as 'mercy', 'control of the mind', 'control of the senses', etc.[114] He adds that this guru must be well versed in the Vedas (shrotriyam) and be centered with Brahman (brahma-nishtha), having relinquished the performance of all karmas.[114]

A guru is someone more than a teacher, traditionally a reverential figure to the student, with the guru serving as a "counselor, who helps mold values, shares experiential knowledge as much as literal knowledge, an exemplar in life, an inspirational source and who helps in the spiritual evolution of a student.[115] The guru, states Joel Mlecko, is more than someone who teaches specific type of knowledge, and includes in its scope someone who is also a "counselor, a sort of parent of mind and soul, who helps mold values and experiential knowledge as much as specific knowledge, an exemplar in life, an inspirational source and who reveals the meaning of life."[115]

Pramana (means of knowledge)

[edit]

In classical Indian thought, pramana (means of knowledge) concerns questions like how correct knowledge can be acquired; how one knows, how one does not; and to what extent knowledge pertinent about someone or something can be acquired.[116][117] In contrast to other schools of Indian philosophy, early Vedanta paid little attention to pramana.[118] The Brahmasutras are not concerned with pramana, and pratyaksa (sense-perception) and anumana (inference) refer there to sruti and smriti respectively.[118] Shankara recognized the means of knowledge,[119][note 25] but his thematic focus was upon metaphysics and soteriology, and he took for granted the pramanas.[124] For Shankara, sabda is the only means of knowledge for attaining Brahman-jnana.[125] According to Sengaku Mayeda, "in no place in his works [...] does he give any systematic account of them",[124] taking Atman-Brahman to be self-evident (svapramanaka) and self-established (svatahsiddha), and "an investigation of the means of knowledge is of no use for the attainment of final release."[124]

Nevertheless, the Advaita tradition accepts altogether six kinds of pramāṇas.[126][127][128][125] While Adi Shankara emphasized Śabda (शब्द), relying on word, testimony of past or present reliable experts with regard to religious insights,[117][129][126][130] and also accepted pratyakṣam (प्रत्यक्षम्), perception; and anumāṇam (अनुमानम्), inference; classical Advaita Vedānta, just like the Bhatta Purvamimamsaka school, also accepts upamāṇam (उपमानम्), comparison, analogy; arthāpattih (अर्थापत्तिः), postulation, derivation from circumstances;[117][131] and anupalabdhih (अनुपलब्धिः), non-perception, negative/cognitive proof.[129][126]

Samadhi

[edit]

According to Dubois, Shankara's Advaita emphasizes that, since Brahman is ever-present, Brahman-knowledge is immediate and requires no 'action', that is, striving and effort;[36] yet, the contemporary Advaita tradition, which is a yogic Advaita synthesis which developed in the late mediaeval period, also prescribes elaborate preparatory practice, including yogic samadhi, posing a paradox which is also recognized in other spiritual disciplines and traditions.[132][42][note 10]

Shankara regarded the srutis as the means of knowledge of Brahman, and he was ambivalent about yogic practices and meditation, which at best may prepare one for Brahma-jnana.[web 5] According to Rambachan, criticising Vivekananda, Shankara states that the knowledge of Brahman can only be obtained from inquiry of the Shruti, and not by Yoga or samadhi, which at best can only silence the mind.[133] The Bhamati school and the Vivarana school differed on the role of contemplation, but they both "deny the possibility of perceiving supersensuous knowledge through popular yoga techniques."[134] Later Advaita texts like the Dṛg-Dṛśya-Viveka (14th century) and Vedāntasara (of Sadananda) (15th century) added samādhi as a means to liberation, a theme that was also emphasized by Swami Vivekananda.[44] The Vivekachudamani, traditionally attributed to Shankara but post-dating him,[135] "conceives of nirvikalpa samadhi as the premier method of Self-realization over and above the well-known vedantic discipline of listening, reflection and deep contemplation."[67] Koller states that yogic concentration is an aid to gaining knowledge in Advaita.[136]

Anubhava ('experience')

[edit]

The role of anubhava, anubhuti ("experience", "intuition"[137]) as "experience" in gaining Brahman-jnana is contested. While neo-Vedanta claims a central position for anubhava as "experience", Shankara himself regarded reliance on textual authority as sufficient for gaining Brahman-jnana,[138][note 26] "the intuition of Brahman",[137] and used anubhava interchangeably with pratipatta, "understanding".[139] Arvind Sharma argues that Shankara's own "direct experience of the ultimate truth" guided him in selecting "those passages of the scriptures that resonate with this experience and will select them as the key with which to open previously closed, even forbidden, doors."[140][note 27]

The Vivekachudamani "explicit[ly] declar[es] that experience (anubhuti) is a pramana, or means of knowing (VCM 59),"[67] and neo-Vedanta also accepts anubhava ("personal experience") as a means of knowledge.[141] Dalal and others state that anubhava does not center around some sort of "mystical experience", but around the correct knowledge of Brahman.[93][142] Nikhalananda concurs, stating that (knowledge of) Atman and Brahman can only be reached by buddhi, "reason",[143] stating that mysticism is a kind of intuitive knowledge, while buddhi is the highest means of attaining knowledge.[144]

Adhyaropa Apavada – imposition and negation

[edit]

Since Gaudapada,[145] who adopted the Buddhist four-cornered negation which negates any positive predicates of 'the Absolute',[146][147][note 28] a central method in Advaita Vedanta to express the inexpressable is the method called Adhyaropa Apavada.[145] In this method, which was highly estimated by Satchidanandendra Saraswati, a property is imposed (adhyaropa) on Atman to convince one of its existence, whereafter the imposition is removed (apavada) to reveal the true nature of Atman as nondual and undefinable.[149] In this method, "That which cannot be expressed is expressed through false attribution and subsequent denial."[150] As Shankara writes, "First let me bring them on the right path, and then I will gradually be able to bring them round to the final truth afterwards."[150] For example, Atman, the real "I", is described as witness, giving "it" an attribute to separate it from non-self. Since this implies a duality between observer and observed, next the notion of "witness" is dropped, by showing that the Self cannot be seen and is beyond qualifications, and only that what is remains, without using any words: