The Programmers’ Identity Crisis: how do we use our powers for ‘good’?

Reading Time: 13 minutes

By the way, you can listen to me read this post aloud on my Patreon, along with many other audio recordings.

In December of 2021, an itinerant sci-fi and fantasy gathering called Worldcon came under scrutiny for accepting a sponsorship from an American defense company.1

Critics remarked that the conference had clearly lost its way. Its guests love fiction that treats space and war as backdrops to imagine a better world. The Worldcon organizers, they argued, had forgotten this context, figuring guests would go “Spaaace, ooh, aahhh.” They had taken money from an organization that profits from war: that engages with space as an adversarial strategic theater. Aligning the con with ethically repugnant organizations based on matching wallpaper, they explained, betrayed fans of the genre.

One of the conference’s guests, in response to the public critique, tweeted a counterargument. I’m paraphrasing to protect the person from a pile on; please don’t try to find them. The gist:

“These defense companies are not necessarily evil. They might be a grey area, but they do good things! After all, my partner works at one, and he is good. I used to work at one, and that one helped with the moon landing, which was good.”2

I watch something like this play out pretty often in tech.

A person thinks of themselves as good (or they date someone ostensibly good), and the good person works for a company that does bad things, so now they have to rationalize what’s happening. A lot of people have to do this, because many companies do bad things, and because capitalism deliberately centralizes power in a way that forces people, eventually, to depend on companies that do bad things.

Few modern industries encapsulate the consolidation of power within a few boardrooms better than tech. Take Amazon as an example: a company that we more or less all acknowledge as evil, but must also acknowledge has such a chokehold on the logistics market that to ask people to switch usually fails to address meaningful accessibility challenges. It also ignores the fact that Amazon services a sizeable subset of both the U.S. government supply chain and also, at time of writing, about 40% of internet traffic.

Additionally, for historical reasons, the tech field specifically maintains this pernicious fantasy that we’re saving the world. Modern consumer technology made its debut into an era of optimistic popular activism. The autumn of 1969 gave us:

  • The first bank ATM (Rockville, New York)
  • The first permanent ARPANET link (the precursor to the internet, developed at UCLA and University of Utah)
  • The first Woodstock Festival (the famous one, on a farm in New York)
  • The month-long Moratorum To End the War in Vietnam (spearheaded in D.C. but executed across the United States)

The zeitgeist, particularly among 15-35 year olds at this time and place, focused on a cultural intention to bring the world3 together in peace and love: in a word, to save it.

The tech industry’s progenitors? Fundamentally sixties kids. The idea of world-saving still captures hearts, so we never did away with it. But that self-image creates cognitive dissonance for those captured hearts. Techies had a hard time saying “I know crypto is burning the planet, but I want to retire early, so I’ve got money in it.” When they leverage an exploitative technology for personal gain, they have to pretend they don’t know about the exploitation, or at least hotly contest it. The alternative requires grappling with a really hard question:

What does it mean about a person to aid a company that—aw, crap, turns out—does bad things?


A few characteristics have made this question particularly biting and cruel for our embattled tech workers and enthusiasts. Let us count the ways.

Thing 1: The Myth of Individualism


Western culture—a behemoth influence, as we’ve established, on tech culture—maintains this idea that our individual choices are the most important, meaningful ones. That it is all up to us, right now, to fix things, and if we can’t or don’t, we are individually evil. We see this value reflected in precisely the media culture represented at WorldCon: science fiction and fantasy epics frequently follow a singular chosen hero—with maybe some sidekicks. The Hero’s Journey offers a compelling narrative, but what it doesn’t do very well is mimic the reality of how things happen—particularly things that benefit the greater good. Good Samaritanism happens all the time on the individual level, but I think humans’ individual self-interest prevents social welfare at scale from happening without a collective project that has widely distributed its power, rather than centralized it.

Where does this leave individuals trying to make things better? Without some realistic and sobering guidance, in despair. Techies want to direct their superior intellects4 at the grievous problem and invent the solution themselves. When a tech company does manage to produce something visionary, tech historians and journalists (shame!) retcon the effort onto One Heroic Man—casting aside the complexity, the hidden figures, and the boredom that infuse the true primordial ooze of progress. Who wouldn’t want the cachet and presumed moral superiority of the Steve Jobs character, that Paul Atreides of Personal Computing? Bad Things, Inc. often snipes optimistic programmers with precisely a promise that here, on this team, they can do just that—and once one accepts that promise, it’s hard to let go of hope.

Thing 2: The Centralization of Capital


In the United States, a few companies draw increasing money and power from a widening wealth gap atop a populace that depends on employment for survival. We have no universal basic income, not even universal health insurance. On top of that, as is the case many places, U.S. immigration status often depends on employment.

That means it’s not uncommon to face a survival necessity to work in service of an unsavory organization. Not everyone has the privilege of choosing from the greatest good or the least evil to secure their green card or their Blue Cross Blue Shield card.

These organizations also deliberately take advantage of individualism to create scapegoats. A giant oil company claims that people having house pets is killing the planet (animal husbandry predates the Industrial Revolution—when our C02 emissions cranked skyward for real—by more than ten thousand years). Meanwhile, engineers can go to jail for implementing executives’ duplicitous lawbreaking. Our industry faces the specialized equivalent of big banks systematically depressing wages and pumping up the cost of living while claiming that young adults are poor because they drink Starbucks (a Grande cafe latte runs $3.65) or eat avocado toast (avocados run about $1 apiece). These absurd fallacies make it into the contemporary vernacular because they fit into the cultural narrative of responsibility, despite blatantly ignoring the landscape of capital and power.

Thing 3: Long chains of accountability.

The internet gives us access to unprecedented depth and breadth of information. That includes encyclopedic knowledge, but it also includes tracking friends of friends of friends of friends. I’ve watched people—dedicated activists with decades-long track records—lose Patreon subscribers or get cancelled on social media because someone credited them in a video, and that someone also defended someone else who got dogpiled over a tweet this one time. Every day has a new Twitter Main Character. The pillory stays occupied in the online public square.

We make fun of ‘Satanic Panic’ from the 1980s: the parents who feared that their imperiled children might befriend some kid at school who liked a fantasy roleplaying game about dragons.5 But I think that our susceptibility to zinger fever online pushes us to similarly absurd outcomes. If moral upstandingness requires 4+ degrees of separation from anyone who ever did a bad thing, none of us can hang onto it for very long.

So how do we deal with all this?


Well, one option is to have a nervous breakdown and become a drain on oneself and society.

Not my favorite idea.

Another option is to become Doug, the ascetic pushover from The Good Place whose commitment to avoiding harm brings him to assign himself a three week round trip on foot to memorialize a snail. Doug abdicates all opportunity to make positive impact to avoid all risk of doing the tiniest bad thing.


In the real world this looks like an individual undertaking massive personal inconvenience or even disempowerment to avoid unsavory organizations as power centralization makes them harder and harder to avoid. This could look like a road trip from Chicago to Seattle, for example, to pick up some pieces of bamboo, because any company that ships the stuff hosts with Amazon.6

The third option is to grit our teeth and rationalize. And I think this is where we get “Defense companies are a grey area.” Or “crypto is in fact a diverse community and that’s how I know its critics are wrong.” Or “Putting a man on the moon was worth it, right?


…right?”

Or, another flavor of this rationalization strategy, “My tattoos and artsy side hobbies prove I’m cool and progressive even if I blithely sling code for the highest bidder and ignore my impact.” Again, matching wallpaper does not mean alignment. By the same token, belonging to an axis of marginalization—let’s say, being femme—does not make an individual capital grab inherently a feminist act. What you do with that power, maybe. But having it alone? Not so.

Okay. So where does that leave us?


In hell.

I’m kidding (sort of).

First of all,

We can develop a more nuanced understanding of where our impact lies. That makes it easier for us to allocate our efforts for greatest impact within our risk tolerance or our cost budget. I wrote about this once upon a time. I still think it’s a useful framework, particularly for folks from a tech background who need a place to start with questions like:

“Should I work there? What impact will it have if I do or if I don’t?”

“Should I spend 5x as much and hand over my address and credit card info to a sketchy website to buy my KN-95s without supporting Amazon?”

Second of all,

We can own up to the rationalizations we’re using when we choose to perfunctorily participate in capitalism with organizations we don’t support. I think our options for participation encompass an entire spectrum between “Drink the techbro kool-aid” and “take up subsistence farming in rural Saskatchewan.” We can possess grievances about systems in which we participate. We can also more meaningfully navigate that dichotomy when we can acknowledge it.

Third of all,

We can recognize that these ethical tradeoffs have systemic causes, and they’ll require systemic solutions.

My recommendation: find a group that you trust in its efforts to create systemic solutions. Ask for the unsexiest, most incremental thing they need help with, and do that.

I know. This is the last thing any techie wants to hear, myself included. You think I’m immune to any of this? I wanna be a hero too. I dream of writing some genius software doodad that non-negligibly contributes to rescuing our planet from climate catastrophe. I want to personally save the whales and design the multi-generational queer utopia. The thing is, I’m just one person, and I only know so many things, and I don’t even speak whale. So you know what I do instead? I donate to World Central Kitchen and mutual aid groups. I invest my 401(k) in a renewable energy ETF, and my savings account in socially responsible portfolios. I volunteer to take notes at town hall meetings about bike lanes. I help formerly incarcerated people learn to code.

Here’s the dirty secret: most of the good we can do, as programmers, doesn’t involve our ‘powers.’

I don’t think any of the most important contributions I’ve made to the Greater Good have anything to do with my talents or proclivities. I think they come from volunteering to perform boring, clerical gopher tasks for organizations focused on systemic change. A brighter future doesn’t come from one person spearheading some buzzword-filled tech effort. My all-time greatest hit on The Bird Site amounted to a poem about this (abridged here):

I have four times witnessed machine learning whizzes
gather in a room to reinvent transport
for eco-friendliness and human convenience.

All four times, they “invented” buses.
All four times.

I witnessed each with my eyeballs.
I’m not counting, say,

the time El-n M-sk, to reinvent transportation, invented the bus,
or the time Via, to reinvent transportation, invented the bus,
or the time Uber, to reinvent transportation, invented the bus.

Buses:
Plentiful routes close to everyone’s origin and destination.
Accessibility for those who cannot walk or take the stairs.
Pull cords to mitigate unnecessary stops.
Elastic capacity and easy rerouting.
Backward compatibility with roads.

They exist. Already.

“Not enough buses,” critics say.
“Traffic blocks buses.”
These aren’t problems with buses.

When people ask “can AI save us?” I think
“If AI can save us, listening to folks who didn’t grow up rich
can save us for like a millionth the cost of AI trying to save us.”

It sounds sexy
to find simple solutions for complex, pressing problems.
But, when it can be done, it’s not sexy.

It’s decidedly boring and pleibian. “Add buses.”

Do with that what you will.

I hope “what you will” is to go help the people in your town already trying to add buses (or bike lanes, or pedestrian routes, or whatever works for your situation). It doesn’t have to be transit: invest in your cause of choice. Healthcare access; public education; public services; the options boggle the mind.

You won’t go down in history as the genius mastermind behind The Tech that Saved the World. You probably won’t even invent the iPhone. But then again, neither did anybody else.

Footnotes

  1. For the record, an individual organizer took full responsibility for the decision and arranged for both organizational and personal donations to attempt to make things right. Also, to give you some additional context that you should have before you pillory this woman, I have it on good authority that this instance of the con teetered on the edge of total institutional implosion and possibly last-second cancellation until she swooped in to save it; an act that required her to make a lot of decisions in a massive hurry, among them this Raytheon decision. This article is not license to go dog some woman for something that happened four years ago. Instead, a public response to that decision exemplifies a broader point I’m making about technocrat apologism. ↩︎
  2. There is no grey area on whether U.S. Defense companies do bad things. Straight up, the U.S. Department of Defense, the foundation client for U.S. defense companies, was renamed to that in 1949 from its original name, the U.S. Department of War. Why? In short, to abdicate explicit reference to advancing the national interest through extrajudicial killing and imperialism. But *waves hands at history* the means and the ends clearly stayed the same. ↩︎
  3. Every single event I listed there happened in the United States. This movement, to my knowledge, did little to examine the role of American exceptionalism and cultural individualism in its tactical choices—an examination that might have saved it from the systematic kibosh brought down in the Reagan era about a decade later. ↩︎
  4. As they say in francophone regions, non comment. ↩︎
  5. A Dungeons and Dragons player myself, I reserve the right to be this reductive. ↩︎
  6. Real example. I will not be taking further questions at this time. ↩︎

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.