A Meditation on Two Old Photographs
*
Please note that this post may be difficult and upsetting to read for some people. Rest assured that I haven’t abandoned Local Walks, I am just expanding the purview of this blog.
**

**
It’s not Joni’s river that I was skating away on, it was
my own skid into oblivion, away from the day
that shattered sweet innocence.
It began with a casual conversation
in Tompkins Square Park,
heart of New York’s counter culture,
leafy and calm
on that mid-August afternoon in 1967.
*
The talk evolved. There was an invitation
she was too polite to refuse. Was she unwilling? Yes
but too polite to refuse, and
too innocent to know what might happen.
The brick wall – (“What should I do with my brick wall?” he asked,
“Won’t you come look?”) – if only there hadn’t been a brick wall
but there would have been another ruse so up she went
oblivious in her innocence, polite, curious, open.
Too open. On the kitchen counter
a row of knives, nothing else.
Many locks on the old wooden door
a radio, a mattress on the floor.
Perhaps a light?
I don’t remember. She didn’t register that.
He insisted that she dance with him
by the brick wall to forgotten music
on a cheap radio.
(Did you notice that she became I
and I became she? Pieces, that’s what was left
after that day in August).
*
The atmosphere changes abruptly –
he has her where he wants her and
now her memory is tearing away from itself
the dark clods of it shoved into a dark corner.
I do remember floating
above myself, watching him hurt her.
The split complete: me/her.
There are no bandaids
for that desperate, unconscious break
from the terror as one part is thinking
do whatever is required.
Get out alive.
I do remember pure, wordless fear
a torn dress, my bodymind in shock,
tightly frozen as I leave
because after he had what he wanted
he carefully controlled my exit, walked me down the stairs
and out onto the street. The terror
finally lowered by a hair
once I was far down the block
merging with people on the sidewalk
yet completely
utterly apart.
*
By then oblivion had taken hold,
seeping into the nooks and crannies
of my young brain eager to discover
a new life in the city, away from home,
without any concept of safety or how to say
“No
I won’t go to your apartment.”
“No!”
The words, the idea – not in my vocabulary.
*
And afterward language wasn’t enough
couldn’t encompass the event
couldn’t touch it.
My body still there on that floor
my mind
uneasy with itself
living a pretense that
none of it ever happened.
______

**
I see her baby face in photographs taken four years
after the Forgetting.
Pieces of her are squeezed into a dark, firmly closed box
so she’s a part of things, and
she’s apart from things.
They are all friends and lovers intermingling
and shining alone,
taboo-breakers, art-makers,
alive in a lucky moment of time
where freedom reigns
except for her the present
bears the unbearable weight of the past,
a past that as a poet has said* was
a living, breathing, hindering beast
a beast that unbeknownst to her
was cramming her life into destructive patterns
in random meetings with people kind and unkind.
Some very unkind.
*
But that’s another story. In this moment
her taboo-breaking,
art-making circle,
with their cigarettes and beer, their bodies
and inchoate dreams shared freely,
in this moment
she is actually safe.
***
* “I had in mind a sense of time in which the past is not past, but a living, breathing, hindering beast.“ Grace Yee: 5 Questions with Grace Yee; Liminal Magazine, 06/15/25.
***
So who are the people in the photos?
In the top picture Kitty’s on the left and my head is in her lap. She paints abstracts now. We were once lovers but it didn’t last long. We separated gently, easily. In the middle is Sybil, a serious thinker who was older than the rest of us. Her husband was a lawyer, a good man. He died of cancer and later she did, too. The last I heard about her, she was working with a Tibetan Buddhist teacher. And then there’s Terry, a larger-than-life man with a generous heart who died far too young from AIDS in 1985. In 1986 I received a postcard from him on Valentine’s Day. I was shocked. How could this be? It was impossible. I later learned that for his final artwork, he made paintings on postcards and gave his partner a list of people to mail them to. It was deeply moving.
In the bottom picture Kitty’s still on the left. Sibyl has her arms around Terry in the back. In the front is Andrius, the son of two Lithuanian immigrant doctors. He taught me how to count in Lithuanian. He and Kitty supposedly got married even though she was gay and he was rumored to be bisexual. They didn’t really get married but that’s a story for another time. Andrius made big paintings of outer space. We were lovers, too, for a while. Now he lives in a big, old house in the French countryside with his artist wife. Then there’s Carl. Sweet, funny, and slightly removed, he always seemed driven by an ineffable, existential quest. I think he’s living on a farm in New Jersey now.
Who’s behind the camera? David, a shy Midwesterner whose comfort behind a camera led him to a successful career photographing expensive jewelry for top New York City auction houses. One of his kids, his daughter Z, is an artist. David prefers making things by hand now, like paintings of scenes that express intense emotions. On 9/11 David’s downtown loft filled with the fine gray dust of thousands of pieces of paper and bodies. The family moved out until their home was clean and habitable again. Now they live in a bucolic house with a barn, two hours north of the city.
**
As you have probably guessed, this text recalls a rape that happened over 50 years ago. One consequence of that incident is that I’m very uncomfortable with that word; I don’t like to hear it, say it, or even type it. I was young, innocent, and virginal when I was tricked into going to that stranger’s apartment. There was no Women’s Movement and certainly no Me Too movement then. Sexual assault was understood to be the victim’s fault. For all those reasons and more, I didn’t tell my parents. I tried calling the NYPD (New York City Police) but that was useless – I didn’t have full name of the perpetrator and I didn’t know the address.
I went on with my life as if that day didn’t happen because there didn’t seem to be any other path forward. Like other victims of violent sexual assault, I was numb and confused and unable to make good choices in relationships. The hindering beast of dissociated memory didn’t disappear. But in spite of my emotional vulnerability, the friends in these photographs never took advantage of me. I felt safe with them and I thank them for that.
***

































































































































