An excerpt from Rachel Held Evan’s book Inspired: Slaying Giants, Walking on Water, and Loving the Bible Again
“Growing up, I noticed the ugly details in the Sunday school
stories; children always do. I remember I was deeply troubled by the
fact that God drowned all but two of each kind of animal in the Great
Flood (to say nothing of all the people), and wondered aloud at the
dinner table how God could be all-knowing and all-powerful, but also
filled with regret. A friend’s seven-year-old captured the angst well
when she recently asked, ‘Mom, is God the good guy or the bad guy in
this story?’
This question of God’s character
haunted every scene and every act and every drama of the Bible.
…Feminist scholar Phyllis Trible aptly named these narratives 'texts
of terror.’
'If art imitates life,’ she wrote, 'scripture likewise reflects it in both holiness and horror.’
Rereading
the texts of terror as a young woman, I kept anticipating some sort of
postscript or epilogue chastising the major players for their sins, a
sort of Arrested Development-style 'lesson’ to wrap it all up – 'And that’s why you should always challenge the patriarchy!’ But no such epilogue exists. While women are raped, killed, and divided as plunder, God stands by, mute as clay.
I waited for a word from God, but none came.
…When
I turned to pastors and professors for help, they urged me to set aside
my objections, to simply trust that God is good and that the Bible’s
war stories happened as told, for reasons beyond my comprehension.
'God’s ways are higher than our ways,’ they insisted. 'Stop trying to know the mind of God.’
It’s
an understandable approach. Human beings are finite and fallible, prone
to self-delusion and sentimentality. If we rely exclusively on our
feelings to guide us to truth, we are bound to get lost.
When
asked in 2010 about Joshua’s conquest of Canaan, Reformed pastor and
theologian John Piper declared, without hesitation, 'It’s right for God
to slaughter women and children anytime he pleases. God gives life and
he takes life. Everybody who dies, dies because God wills that they
die.’
Piper’s dispassionate acceptance
represented pure, committed faith, I was told, while mine had been
infected by humanism and emotion – 'a good example of why women should
be kept from church leadership,’ one acquaintance said.
And
for a moment, I believed it. For a moment, I felt silly for responding
so emotionally to a bunch of old war stories that left the rest of the
faithful seemingly unfazed.
But this is the deleterious snare of
fundamentalism: It claims that the heart is so corrupted by sin, it
simply cannot be trusted to sort right from wrong, good from evil,
divine from depraved. Instinct, intuition, conscience, critical thinking
– these impulses must be set aside whenever they appear to contradict
the biblical text, because the good Christian never questions the 'clear
teachings of Scripture’; the good Christian listens to God, not her
gut.
I’ve watched people get so entangled in
this snare they contort into shapes unrecognizable. When you can’t trust
your own God-given conscience to tell you what’s right, or your own
God-given conscience to tell you what’s true, you lose the capacity to
engage the world in any meaningful, authentic way, and you become an
easy target for authoritarian movements eager to exploit that vacuity
for their gain. I tried reading Scripture with my conscience and
curiosity suspended, and I felt, quite literally, disintegrated. I felt
fractured and fake.
Brené Brown warned
us we can’t selectively numb our emotions, and no doubt this applies to
the emotions we have about our faith. If the slaughter of Canaanite children elicits only a shrug, then why not the slaughter of Pequots? Of Syrians? Of Jews?
If we train ourselves not to ask hard questions about the Bible, and to
emotionally distance ourselves from any potential conflicts or doubts,
then where will we find the courage to challenge interpretations that
justify injustice? How will we know when we’ve got it wrong?
'Belief
in a cruel god makes a cruel man,’ Thomas Paine said. If the Bible
teaches that God is love, and love can look like genocide and violence
and rape, then love can look like…anything. It’s as much an invitation to moral relativism as you’ll find anywhere.
I
figured if God was real, then God didn’t want the empty devotion of
some shadow version of Rachel, but rather my whole, integrated self. So I
decided to face the Bible’s war stories head-on, mind and heart fully
engaged, willing to risk the loss of faith if that’s where the search
led.
I listened to sermons. I read commentaries and theology books. I became a real downer at dinner parties:
'If you could travel anywhere in the world, where would you go?’
'Have you seen any of the Oscar-nominated films this year?’
'What’s your Enneagram number?’
'Do you think God condones genocide?’
The explanations came hurried and certain.
Oh,
God told Israel to wipe out the Canaanites because the Canaanites were
super-duper evil, like the worst people ever. They worshipped idols and
had orgies and sacrificed children to their gods.
So God condemned the practice of child sacrifice…by slaughtering children?
Well,
that’s just how things were back then. It was kill or be killed, tribal
warfare and all that. Israel did what it had to do to survive….
I began to feel a bit like the disheveled Berenger, a character from Eugène Ionesco’s play Rhinoceros, who
grows increasingly bewildered as the people of his provincial French
town acclimate to the sudden presence of rhinoceroses in their
community. In one scene, a rhinoceros thunders through the town square,
trampling a housecat. After their initial shock, the villagers get
sidetracked debating whether the rhino had one horn or two, and whether
its origins are Asiatic or African. And on it goes throughout the play,
as the townspeople themselves transform into rhinos, one by one, arguing
all the while over pointless trivialities, until only Berenger remains
human.
The play is about fascism, I think, but it reminds me a
bit of Christians and their Bibles. Sometimes it seems as if there are
all these rhinoceroses barreling through the pages of Scripture, pooping
on sidewalks and flattening housecats, but we’ve grown so accustomed to
defending their presence we end up debating the length of their tails.
…
My
questions came with consequences. We left the church in which I was
raised, and rumors of my 'rebellious spirit’ circulated around town,
prompting more than a few well-meaning interventions. …
But accepting the Bible’s war stories without objection threatened to erase my humanity. ‘We
don’t become more spiritual by becoming less human,’ Eugene Peterson
said. How could I love God with all my heart, soul, mind, and strength
while disengaging those very faculties every time I read the Bible?
So I brought my whole self into the wilderness with God – no faking, no halfway. And there we wrestled.“