ONE SPIRIT, MANY GIFTS (Posts tagged hell)

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna
sacredheart-stigmata
sacredheart-stigmata

Jesus talks in Luke 16 about a rich man who ignored a poor beggar named Lazarus who was inside his gate. They both die, and the rich man goes to Hades, while Lazarus is "carried" by angels to "Abraham's side". [...] The rich man asks Abraham to have Lazarus go get him some water, because he is "in agony in this fire."

[...] Note what it is this man wants in hell: he wants Lazarus to get him water. The rich man wants Lazarus to serve him. In their previous life, the rich man saw himself as better than Lazarus, and now, in hell, the rich man still sees himself as above Lazarus. It's no wonder Abraham says there's a chasm that can't be crossed. The chasm is the rich man's heart! It hasn't changed, even in death and torment and agony. He's still clinging to the old hierarchy. He still thinks he's better.

[...] To reject Lazarus was to reject God. The rich man Jesus tells us about hasn’t yet figured that out. He’s still clinging to his ego, his status, his pride—he’s unable to let go of the world he’s constructed, which puts him on the top and Lazarus on the bottom, the world where Lazarus served him.

He's dead, but he hasn't died-- he's in Hades, but he still hasn't died the death that brings Life. [The death of greed, of cruelty to one's neighbour. The death of his own place in the oppressor class]. He’s living with the reality that comes from not dying that death that will lead a person into the only Life that will ever be worth living.

Lazarus and the Rich Man and what they can teach us about Christian Hell as seen in Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Has Ever Lived

lazarus lazarus and the rich man luke 16 hell reading and studying the bible

Anonymous asked:

i dont believe people go to hell for not being christian. i just can’t fathom that God would have sent me the best friends and partners any person could ask for, just to make me spend eternity without them. that would be crueler than any punishment in hell.

I’m with you, anon! In fact, I don’t personally believe in hell at all, for similar reasons to yours — it seems like a very human response to the problem of sin; a God who is wise and all-loving must be able to imagine justice that goes far beyond the punitive or exilic. I write more on this over here.

And even if hell does exist, I agree with you that people don’t go there just for being non-Christian. Throughout scripture we find a God who is far more concerned with how people act than what people believe.

I highly recommend the book Holy Envy by Barbara Brown Taylor for a text on respecting people of all faiths and celebrating the unique insights into the divine that each one offers. You can read some excerpts from the book here.

More stuff you might enjoy exploring:

hell interfaith relationships
thiefree
lifeinpoetry

““Hell is other people” is only one side of the coin. The other side, which no one seems to mention, is also “Heaven is each other”. Hell is separateness, uncommunicability, self-centeredness, lust for power, for riches, for fame. Heaven on the other hand is very simple, and very hard: caring about your fellow beings. And that’s possible on a sustained basis only in collectivity.”

— Jean-Paul Sartre; in “Talking with Sartre” (p. 130) [edited] (via insearchofwisdom)

quote tag hell heaven

Anonymous asked:

Catholic here. How do I get over the fear that God is going to send me to hell for being trans and gay? I sincerely believe in Catholicism, but the traditional view re: gay love and relationships I'm finding harder and harder to hold, but I'm also afraid that I'm wrong, and I don't want to offend God and I have no desire to leave Catholicism, which in every other theological respect I love. Sorry for the long message. I just don't know what to do with the anxiety I get sometimes about it all. God bless and thanks.

Hey there, anon. I feel for you — while I personally have moved away from institutional Catholicism / the Roman Catholic Church, I still identify strongly as Catholic in how I experience Divinity and community. There is so much beauty in the Catholic faith! It is not right that we are so often made to choose between the tradition we call home and embracing the way God created us.

You’re also not alone in these anxieties around hell. Too many Christians attempt to “bring people to God” through fear, rather than love — even though “their is no fear in love” (1 John 4:18); and Jesus came to invite us into wholeness and abundance, into genuine relationship, not terror! I will be praying for you, that these fears might ease in time and that God will help you truly feel Their deep, unconditional love for you. <3

_______

Do gay people go to hell? What about “mistaken” people?

I obviously don’t believe it is sinful to be LGBTQA+. I fervently believe that God created all of us as diverse so that together, humanity reflects the Vastness of God’s own Self; and that embracing and living into our LGBT/queer identities is a way of saying “yes” to the God who made us this way! If / when you struggle to believe that, wandering through my #affirmation tag might offer you some encouragement.

Meanwhile, I totally feel you on the worry that, even if most of you believes that God does affirm and embrace LGBTQA+ folk, there’s that little what if in the back of the mind: “what if it turns out I’m mistaken? Won’t God be angry — maybe even mad enough to send me to hell??”

But the good news is that even if we are wrong, God is a God of compassion, of understanding of our limitedness — Xe doesn’t ship people off to hell for getting elements of theology wrong!

We can pray for God’s Spirit to give us the wisdom to discern what God’s will is; but at the end of the day, our finite minds won’t get everything right. And that’s okay — because heaven isn’t a reward for getting the best grade on a theology test: heaven is a gift from God to us, pure and simple. That can be hard to digest, but it’s the core of Jesus’s message: we don’t earn salvation; it’s given freely and joyfully to us by the God who longs to be with us forever. There is nothing you can be or do to cancel out that gift.

_

Finally, for the official Roman Catholic stance, since it may provide you some comfort: Catholic doctrine does not state that LGBTQA+ people go to hell — “not even” those who “act on” being gay, trans, etc.

Catholic teaching around LGBTQA+ persons centers around compassion and understanding towards us. It does also teach that we should abstain from sex, can’t get married, etc., and claims that gay sex is a sin — but, unlike some other non-affirming denominations, Catholicism does not elevate the “sin” of gayness above other sins. It’s not an “unforgivable” sin; it’s not The Worst Sin; it’s not a damnable sin.

Obviously I’m not giving the Catholic Church a pass when it comes to its homophobia and transphobia, but yeah — while there are individual clergy members who teach against official doctrine and claim gay people go to hell, that is not what the official doctrine says. So while it’s not a perfect stance, I hope that knowledge helps ease some of your fears.

Meanwhile, there are so many Catholics out there who disagree with anti-LGBT doctrine!

There are so many individual nuns, priests, laypersons, etc. who are in your corner! —

In fact, according to the Pew Research Center (2020), about three quarters of Catholics in the USA say society should be accepting of “homosexuality.” Catholics in many other countries have even higher rates of that acceptance, such 95% in the Netherlands and 93% in Germany.

There are also lots of fabulous Catholic groups that advocate for LGBTQA+ folk:

  • DignityUSA works for respect and justice for people of all sexual orientations, genders, and gender identities—especially gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender persons—in the Catholic Church and the world through education, advocacy, and support. You can see if there’s a local chapter near you on the site!
  • New Ways Ministry (thanks to @c4bl3fl4m3 for reminding me about this group!!) has been advocating for justice, equality, and reconciliation within the larger church and civil communities since the late 1970s.
    .
  • The Progressive Catholic Voice is an “independent and grassroots forum for reflection, dialogue, and the exchange of ideas within the Catholic community of Minnesota and beyond.” It’s not LGBT specific, but here’s a link to all the posts that have been categorized as LGBT.
    .
  • The Wild Reed is a blog by Michael J. Bayly, an Australian who resides in the US and who served as the executive coordinator of the Catholic Pastoral Committee on Sexual Minorities (CPCSM) from 2003-2015. This blog has been churning out posts since 2006(!), with the most recent post being about Lil Nas X coming out. Lots of older posts review books, talk about queer Saints, and more.

Remembering that there are countless Catholics on your side can be a huge encouragement when facing fears that God doesn’t accept you. You are supported, you are loved, and you don’t have to choose between embracing your whole self & being Catholic.

_____

Is there even a hell at all??

It may help you to start rephrasing ideas around hell, and to explore alternative conceptions of heaven and hell in the Christian community.

  • Instead of thinking of hell as a place God “sends” “bad people,” many Christians (including a lot of Catholics) conceive of hell as a place some people choose to go — “hell’s door is locked from the inside” — the only way to “end up” in hell is to say no to God’s freely offered gift of heaven.
  • Meanwhile, Orthodox tradition holds that heaven and hell are the same “place” — we all end up in the unfiltered presence of God, but to evil people that Presence is agony.
  • And there are some Christians (myself included) who don’t think hell exists at all! (or at least that very few, if any, people end up there.)

Some posts that might help you explore conceptions of hell that don’t lead to being frozen in fear:

______

In closing

Dear anon, you are a beloved child of God. God made you gay, God made you trans, and most simply, God made you — not for suffering, not for fear, but for the purpose of loving and being loved by God.

When it’s hard for you to remember that…

  • Check out those previously linked organizations for a reminder of how many Catholics are in your corner
  • Wander through my #queer and Catholic tag for a reminder that you’re not the only LGBT Catholic; or my #affirmation tag; or my trans Jesus or God beyond gender tags…
  • Reach out to someone you can trust; or take some time to sit quietly with God, asking that They enfold you in their love.

I wish you the best, anon. This kind of fear is hard to shake, but even in the midst of it, you are deeply and eternally loved. Hang in there <3

queer and catholic fear fear of hell long post hell catholic tag

Anonymous asked:

I read a book called Her Gates Will Never Be Shut in an attempt to try to ease my fear of hell and being queer at the same time, but the book said that most people’s interpretations of the passages are just a “false assurance”, and that they could very well be real, and keep dictating God as an angry punisher. I’m so scared, if you could have any sources of your own, I’d really appreciate it. Thank you.

cw fear of hell

Hey there, anon. I’m so sorry you’re stuck in this fear. That sounds like a bad book. God wills our liberation from fear, not our floundering in it! God comes to break our chains, not install new ones!

To me, the “false assurances” are the ones that depict God as Just Like Us – just like human rulers, who indeed tend to be all too happy to toss problematic persons into prison, to shut rebels away to rot rather than install systems that can carry whole communities into right relationship.

But God is not like human beings. God’s justice is not punitive, but restorative.

On my other blog, I recently wrote a little essay about hell and how the concept of a place of eternal punishment shapes God in our image. I recommend you read through that and then, if you have any other questions, please feel free to come back and ask!

Wishing you the best, and an easing of your fear, so that you can be free to live your best, most fruitful life.

hell fear of hell

Anonymous asked:

I feel like if there's punishment in the afterlife it's more purgatory than permanent hell. And it's more for billionaires of the world than having the wrong beliefs. If it's painful it's be more because it would suck to have to acknowledge you acted badly while alive. David Bentley Hart wrote a book about universalism but I haven't finished it yet, but not believing in permahell isn't a wild idea, even for Christians.

This is why I enjoy the concept of Purgatory from my Catholic days! Between death and heaven, there has got to be some space in which true repentance and reconciliation and reform takes place. Otherwise, how on earth can oppressors and oppressed, those who cause harm and the ones they’ve harmed, experience true unity in God’s Kin(g)dom? 

Our God is a God of mercy, but also of justice – true, restorative justice; not purely punitive justice. (For a good book on this topic that applies it to criminal ‘justice’ systems here on earth, see Rethinking Incarceration by Dominique Gilliard.) 

We can’t just have our slates “magically” wiped clean after all the harm that’s been perpetuated here and now – if the space for restoration doesn’t occur on earth, it must occur either between or in the midst of heaven.

hell purgatory heaven Anonymous
queer-spirituality-blog
a-queer-seminarian

“I do know of one preacher who…suggested that the Christian way was one among many ways to God (a wave and not the ocean), because afterward a man came up to her and said, ‘If God isn’t partial to Christianity, what am I doing here?’

…As natural as it may be to want to play on the winning team, the wish to secure divine favoritism strikes me as the worst possible reason to practice any religion. If the man who asked that question could not think of a dozen better reasons to be a Christian than that, then what, indeed, was he doing there?

An old story is told about Rabia of Basra, an eighth-century Sufi mystic who was seen running through the streets of her city one day carrying a torch in one hand and a bucket of water in the other. When someone asked her what she was doing, she said she wanted to burn down the rewards of paradise with the torch and put out the fires of hell with the water, because both blocked the way to God. ‘O, Allah,’ Rabia prayed, ‘if I worship You for fear of Hell, burn me in Hell, and if I worship You in hope of Paradise, exclude me from Paradise. But if I worship You for Your own sake, grudge me not Your everlasting Beauty.’ 

In Christian tradition this comes under the heading of unconditional love, though it is usually understood as the kind of love God exercises toward humans instead of the other way around. Now, thanks to a Muslim mystic from Iraq, I have a new way of understanding what it means to love God unconditionally. Whenever I am tempted to act from fear of divine punishment or hope of divine reward, Rabia leans over from her religion into mine and empties a bucket of water on my head.”

- Barbara Brown Taylor in Holy Envy: Finding God in the Faith of Others

barbara brown taylor holy envy pluralism other faiths tag interfaith quote tag christianity fear of hell hell heaven
apptowonder
girlfriendluvr

image

HEY GOYIM YOU KNOW THATS NOT HOW JUDAISM WORKS AT ALL RIGHT??? like HELL DOESNT EXIST in judaism. we do not believe in hell. and jewish philosophy ENCOURAGES questioning god.

i think the thing ur thinking of is ummmmm Just Fucking Christianity lol. stop trying to lump us in with christians when you clearly dont know the first thing about judaism and assume its a clone of christianity.

(idk much of anything abt islamic philosophy, muslim followers feel free to add on!)

magnusbrownbisexual

hell in islam is reformatory and never permanent unless you’ve done some irredeemable evil, but ultimately, if your good deeds outweigh your “bad” deeds (even if it’s just one (1) thing that’s big enough to outweigh your entire life) then you go straight to heaven. islam rests on “do good unto others and on yourself” and not “don’t do this”…..when will people learn to read. i’m so sorry, op, for people.

we have a ton of stories about the prophet muhammad (pbuh) where he talked about or talked to people that were textbook case ‘sinners’ but still went to heaven because they either never did anything bad to others or they did some enormous good deed. at the end of the day, we believe that only Allah can decide who goes to hell/heaven, even temporarily and who doesn’t, and we are actually forbidden to say things like “you’re going to hell!!!!” because we don’t know which good deed of ours shines so bright in His eyes that all our bad deeds are immediately forgiven.

and there are so many tiny ways to have bad deeds erased? fast once and your past bad deeds are gone. smile and spend time with your parents and Allah builds a house for you in heaven. save someone’s live and you’re good. refuse to talk bad about someone and Allah smiles down on you……hell is mostly just cautionary for the average person because even if the average person does something bad enough they could end up in temporary hell, they will probably do something to redeem themselves before that time comes.

girlfriendluvr

thank you for the information, islam sounds beautiful!!

unculture

Make Atheists Say Christian 2020

timewolf42

And it’s not even Christianity as a whole that preaches the fire-and-brimstone-to-all-sinners thing. I’m Catholic, and the vast majority of other Catholics I’ve spoken to (including priests and other church leaders) are more odd the opinion that hell is only for really, REALLY bad people (i.e., those who have murdered innocent people with absolutely no remorse, etc.).

As Catholics, we believe in purgatory, which is a sort of in-between place. It’s not hell, but it’s not heaven, either. It’s kind of like a waiting room where you work out the bad and good you did during your lifetime. I imagine it sort of like emotional therapy for the recently dead. Like, yeah, there were times you fucked up, but you’re human. All humans fuck up every now and again. That’s part of human nature. You realize what your sins were, understand the consequences they had, repent, then move on. It’s a lot more hopeful than the either-or/heaven-hell binary that many Protestant Christian sects adhere to.

We also believe that God doesn’t send people to hell just for believing differently than we do. It’s more of how you treat others. All in all, I don’t think people go to hell unless they’re such a horrendous, unrepentant person that there’s nothing redeeming in them, and that’s a pretty rare thing.

hey-hey-shutthefuckup

Also, certain denominations believe certain things. Like, I’ve been taught the only thing you can go to hell for is complete and utter blasphemy against God, rejection of him fundamentally by being pure evil. Like, even if you dont profess yourself as Christian, as long as you live your life the way God would have you - as someone seeking the good of humanity and living in love- you will be welcomed to heaven. So like, as long as you’re not a baddie you’re golden. But again, that’s only the belief of certain denominations. I really think the photo is pertaining to “american chrisitans” who legit have no clue about the bible other than what they’re told.

quoththegayven

I’m Lutheran Christian and I was raised to believe that Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross secured a place for everyone in heaven. Meaning that no one really goes to Hell, if Hell even exists. The idea of “Hell as eternal terrible punishment” isn’t even consistent across Christianity.

hell judaism islam

Anonymous asked:

(please answer asap) Hi, I’ve been struggling with anxiety in regards to going to Hell. I’m bi and non-binary, and fully accept that, but whenever I think about the afterlife or anything God/Jesus-related I have panic attacks. I managed to repress my anxiety for a few months, but it came back. Can I please have a prayer and/or reassurance that I won’t go to Hell? Thank you so much if you answer this.

cw hell, fear of hell, panic attacks

Aw my friend, I’m sorry you are going through this. I promise you that God loves you dearly, that Jesus redeems you, and I believe that you are not going to hell. 

You are not alone in experiencing these fears. So many of us grow up in communities that would rather scare us into obeying their rules than teach us an eagerness for God’s Kin(g)dom and a delight in God’s liberation. 

You might find my #hell tag helpful, as well as my #heaven tag! The first third of this post in particular answers another person who is afraid of hell. 

God of unbounded, unconditional love,
Enfold this person in your comfort and peace when they experience this fear. Guide them towards new glimpses of you that reveal your deep love for them and desire to unite with them fully in heaven. May them come to know you not as a punisher waiting to pounce but as their protector. 
Amen.

hell heaven fear of hell Anonymous
god-is-queerer

Anonymous asked:

Do you believe that non-Christians or people who “haven’t been saved “are going to hell? I really like a lot of what you have to say but religious trauma makes me really weary of things like that, and I’d like to know before I follow!

anarchopuppy answered:

No, and I’m not sure I believe in hell at all. I don’t think it’s relevant enough for me to spend a bunch of time wrestling with the question of the afterlife. But suffice to say, no, I don’t believe that

god-is-queerer

if I get to the afterlife and find out there's a permanent hell that relies not on how much harm you've done but on whether you believe the right dogma, I'm planning a jailbreak

!!!! <3 well worded!!! Jesus never insisted we know everything. only that we love. that we liberate. that we listen hell

Anonymous asked:

i often feel like a horrible pos even though people say i'm very sweet and i always worry about if i'll go to heaven or not and idk what to do-

Hey there, anon. I feel you – when I let my mind start listing out all the many many many ways I’ve failed to show up for people, or been cruel to people, or thought or said hateful things, I feel like a pretty horrible person. I feel like a fraud to the people who see me as kind or helpful. The thing is, we all have the potential for meanness within us – but that does not negate our potential for goodness and kindness.

If you worry about whether you are good or not, chances are…you’re not a horrible person! You are a person who desires to be good – which is itself good. A “horrible person” would never pause to wonder if they’re good or bad. 

As to your fear about not going to heaven – there’s a quote that I love from Shirley Guthrie, who says that “heaven is for sinners and hell is for ‘good’ people.” (Click this link for the wider passage that quote is in.) We do not “earn” heaven by being perfect; it’s not a prize we win for ourselves – it’s a gift from God. When we acknowledge our own sinfulness, we are humble enough to accept that gift. 

Pursue your desire to live into the goodness people ascribe to you. Because it really is there! Even if there’s a meaner part of you they don’t see, that doesn’t make the sweet part they see and name “fake” – it’s something you can pursue and cultivate and grow so big it leaves little room for the meanness. 

hell goodness kindness Anonymous heaven fear of hell

image description: a twitter thread by Rev. Emmy Kegler reading,

If your main method of “spreading the good news” is to incite panic attacks in small children by telling them their whole family is going to burn in hell forever because they don’t go to church, 

 I would ask that you … not.

1. It’s borderline (and perhaps not even borderline) abusive to create an ideological system in which the only way a person can survive is to do whatever you say.

2. Most of Jesus’ condemnations were not about where your butt was on Sunday morning but where your actions were the rest of the week: if you used religious authority to oppress the poor (Mt 23), if you ignored the hungry and needy (Mt 25, Lk 16), if you were evil (Jn 5).

3. It’s just bad hermeneutics, y'all. Even IF Scripture didn’t tell us God was a god of love, slow to anger, outlandishly merciful - to read the stories and teachings of Jesus and choose a main message of “the good news is THE WORLD WILL BURN” is a fundamental mis-read.

The God of the Hebrew Bible shows time and time again that repentance and second (and 3rd, 4th, 18th) [chances] are possible. (Also Hell doesn’t exist in it, but that’s a thread for another time.)

Jesus’ main work is to collect those who have been shoved to the edges, bring them back in, and announce the kingdom of God in which salvation is not a faith-based deliverance from God’s inescapable condemnation but ABUNDANT life HERE and NOW.

4. We know good trees by their fruits. Are you teaching kids to be compassionate, justice-seeking, loving? Or are you teaching them to believe everything you say in case your god notices their misbehavior and burns them forever?

Jesus is so much better than this, beloveds. So much more than a bloody sacrifice to a hateful god. 

Jesus is liberation for the captive, real life for the wealthy, community for those excluded, healing for the broken. 

 Please, I beg you, preach THAT.

/end id

proselytizing evangelism church hurt issues in christianity hell fearmongering
lovethyqueers
the-queer-and-beloved

I really need people to realize and respect that queer Christians can and do exist. 

They are not wrong for being queer and they are not wrong for being Christians. They are not traitors to their faith and they are not traitors to their queerness. 

legsdemandias

Also this is really old discourse from a few years ago, but don’t talk about them going to hell, not as a joke either. It’s a really big deal in Christianity to go to hell and it’s not a funny joke–unless they tell you it is. 

bramblepatch

In many cases, openly queer Christians are best positioned and equipped to help closeted queer Christians, and jokes about how we’re going to hell can seriously damage our ability to help our queer siblings in the church. Like, most of us who are comfortable in both aspects of our identities are also comfortable enough in our relationship with God that we can shrug off that kind of talk, but it can be a major stumbling block for people who are still trying to reconcile their faith and their sexuality or gender.

It’s easy to focus on the cartoonish fire-and-brimstone imagery, but in a lot of Christian thought hell and damnation is more fundamentally understood as a state of separation from God. It’s an estrangement from an all-loving and all-nurturing force, and one for which you bear responsibility. An awful lot of people are taught that the way that they experience love puts them at odds with the source and embodiment of all love - that therefore what they experience isn’t really love.

That’s a big part of why the idea that queerness is sinful is so damaging - it’s less about the idea of punishment and more about the idea of being intrinsically flawed in a way that means you can’t trust your own experience of the greatest good. Which is nonsense, humans are flawed beings, but our expansive capacity to connect with and care about each other is one of the best things about us as a species.

Queer Christians exist, and can have just as pure of experience of God’s love and love for other humans as our cishet siblings, and talking about us like we aren’t real or are lying about who we are to trick people makes it much harder for people who have been hurt in the church’s name to trust us. And not all of them will or can seek support from secular groups. If we cannot successfully invite the queer children of God to come to us, some of them may leave the church altogether, but others will get dragged back into communities that hurt them further.

really well put bramblepatch hell fear support dialogue tag

Anonymous asked:

Urgent: I am a Catholic Lesbian. I've read every argument I could find both for and against gay marraige and reached out to queer & Christian blogs. I am terrified of hell, but the thought of being celibate as Catholicism demands is making me miserable. I am so so scared. I just don't know what to do anymore. I feel like I'm losing my faith, which never really brought me any happiness, but I don't want to lose it & I don't know how to shake the fear that if I ever have sex I'll go to hell.

Hi there, dear. My heart really hurts for you. It’s so terrifying and exhausting and distressing and painful to be in the space you’re currently in. I’ll be praying for you – that you can find some comfort and rest; that you can rediscover God as someone who loves you and will keep you safe, not throw you into hell. 

Too many people have been the victims of fear-mongering, of human beings deciding what actions or thoughts get you flung into hell for eternity. That kind of ideology hammers into your psyche, and it’s so hard to free yourself of that fear. It might take you a long, long time to become free of the fear that if you ever have sex you’ll go to hell. I wish there was a quick solution to fix the problem for you, but chances are, this is going to be a long and often difficult journey for you.

The good news is, you don’t have to be on this journey alone. Thank you for reaching out to me and other queer & Christian blogs, for instance! I hope you’ll be able to keep reaching out to people, and gather a support group around you – of friends you trust, folks online, an affirming therapist (and if this is something that obsesses you and severely disrupts your life, I do recommend finding a therapist or other professional help), writers of books and articles that help you…whomever and whatever you can gather to you. And most of all, I pray that God will make Her presence felt to you – a loving, tender, patient presence, not a fearful and judgmental one. 

_______

Okay, all that said, now I’m gonna go through several of the things you mention one at a time: 

“I am terrified of hell” 

  • I’m not sure if doing more research into hell will be helpful to you or not. If you think re-visioning what hell is could be helpful to you, I’ve got a #hell tag where I and other writers discuss hell – is it even real? who goes there? 
  • I was raised Catholic and have studied Catholic views of hell, and one thing that I remember learning is that hell is not a place of punishment where God throws people for doing bad things. Rather, only those who refuse to accept God’s forgiveness – a gift offered to everyone, regardless of how severe or many their sins are – go there. If you say “yes” to God’s grace, you will not go to hell; God will have mercy on you. 
  • You might appreciate this quote by a Protestant named Shirley Guthrie on how “heaven is for sinners and hell is for ‘good’ people.” 
  • I will affirm over and over that being LGBTQA+ is not a sin but part of God’s diversity, that having sex with someone of the same gender is not a sin – but, even if it were a sin, that doesn’t mean that having gay sex sends you straight to hell. We all sin in various ways, and rely on God’s mercy to save us from hell. If you’re still struggling to believe that being gay and having sex is not sinful, that’s okay; for now, know that even if it were a sin, God still loves you and forgives you. If you do have sex with a woman one day and then decide it was wrong for you after all, you can ask for God’s forgiveness; you won’t be sentenced straight to hell for it.

“the thought of being celibate as Catholicism demands is making me miserable.”

  • the Catholic Catechism does indeed instruct that gay persons remain celibate. But I am not the only Catholic to strongly disagree with this instruction. Celibacy is a good and holy thing – when one is called by God to it, when one chooses it for themself, not when it is forced upon a person. I talk about that in my celibacy tag. 
  • For you, I highly recommend a book by Margaret Farley, a Catholic nun (still in good standing! the Catholic Church actually approved her writing this book) called Just Love. In it, Farley discusses what makes a sexual relationship/activity just, i.e., ethical and good in the eyes of God. She comes up with 7 points a relationship that involves sex should fulfill – I share the list and explain it a bit in this post. 
  • Based off her points, I think Farley would agree that for you celibacy would probably not bear good fruit. If the idea of celibacy makes you miserable, it’s probably not your vocation. 

“I feel like I’m losing my faith, which never really brought me any happiness, but I don’t want to lose it…” 

  • It sounds like a big part of your journey is going to be deciding whether the Catholic faith is right for you or not. Right now, you say, it does not bring you happiness – instead, it seems to be bringing you no shortage of misery and fear. 
  • Jesus came that we all might “have life, and have it abundantly” (John 10:10) – not in some future heaven, but right here and now! If your faith is not bringing you abundant life, it’s time to explore other options. 
  • I’m not saying that’s an easy thing to do; it’s not. What you end up doing is up to you. Here is a post where I respond to a person saying that being queer and Catholic feels unbearable, where I offer various options for what they might do. 

Does anyone have more words of comfort or advice for anon?

fear in the valley of the shadow hell anon queerly christian asks homophobia / fear of hell