Hey there, anon. I feel for you — while I personally have moved away from institutional Catholicism / the Roman Catholic Church, I still identify strongly as Catholic in how I experience Divinity and community. There is so much beauty in the Catholic faith! It is not right that we are so often made to choose between the tradition we call home and embracing the way God created us.
You’re also not alone in these anxieties around hell. Too many Christians attempt to “bring people to God” through fear, rather than love — even though “their is no fear in love” (1 John 4:18); and Jesus came to invite us into wholeness and abundance, into genuine relationship, not terror! I will be praying for you, that these fears might ease in time and that God will help you truly feel Their deep, unconditional love for you. <3
_______
Do gay people go to hell? What about “mistaken” people?
I obviously don’t believe it is sinful to be LGBTQA+. I fervently believe that God created all of us as diverse so that together, humanity reflects the Vastness of God’s own Self; and that embracing and living into our LGBT/queer identities is a way of saying “yes” to the God who made us this way! If / when you struggle to believe that, wandering through my #affirmation tag might offer you some encouragement.
Meanwhile, I totally feel you on the worry that, even if most of you believes that God does affirm and embrace LGBTQA+ folk, there’s that little what if in the back of the mind: “what if it turns out I’m mistaken? Won’t God be angry — maybe even mad enough to send me to hell??”
But the good news is that even if we are wrong, God is a God of compassion, of understanding of our limitedness — Xe doesn’t ship people off to hell for getting elements of theology wrong!
We can pray for God’s Spirit to give us the wisdom to discern what God’s will is; but at the end of the day, our finite minds won’t get everything right. And that’s okay — because heaven isn’t a reward for getting the best grade on a theology test: heaven is a gift from God to us, pure and simple. That can be hard to digest, but it’s the core of Jesus’s message: we don’t earn salvation; it’s given freely and joyfully to us by the God who longs to be with us forever. There is nothing you can be or do to cancel out that gift.
_
Finally, for the official Roman Catholic stance, since it may provide you some comfort: Catholic doctrine does not state that LGBTQA+ people go to hell — “not even” those who “act on” being gay, trans, etc.
Catholic teaching around LGBTQA+ persons centers around compassion and understanding towards us. It does also teach that we should abstain from sex, can’t get married, etc., and claims that gay sex is a sin — but, unlike some other non-affirming denominations, Catholicism does not elevate the “sin” of gayness above other sins. It’s not an “unforgivable” sin; it’s not The Worst Sin; it’s not a damnable sin.
Obviously I’m not giving the Catholic Church a pass when it comes to its homophobia and transphobia, but yeah — while there are individual clergy members who teach against official doctrine and claim gay people go to hell, that is not what the official doctrine says. So while it’s not a perfect stance, I hope that knowledge helps ease some of your fears.
Meanwhile, there are so many Catholics out there who disagree with anti-LGBT doctrine!
There are so many individual nuns, priests, laypersons, etc. who are in your corner! —
In fact, according to the Pew Research Center (2020), about three quarters of Catholics in the USA say society should be accepting of “homosexuality.” Catholics in many other countries have even higher rates of that acceptance, such 95% in the Netherlands and 93% in Germany.
There are also lots of fabulous Catholic groups that advocate for LGBTQA+ folk:
- DignityUSA works for respect and justice for people of all sexual orientations, genders, and gender identities—especially gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender persons—in the Catholic Church and the world through education, advocacy, and support. You can see if there’s a local chapter near you on the site!
- New Ways Ministry (thanks to @c4bl3fl4m3 for reminding me about this group!!) has been advocating for justice, equality, and reconciliation within the larger church and civil communities since the late 1970s.
. - The Progressive Catholic Voice is an “independent and grassroots forum for reflection, dialogue, and the exchange of ideas within the Catholic community of Minnesota and beyond.” It’s not LGBT specific, but here’s a link to all the posts that have been categorized as LGBT.
. - The Wild Reed is a blog by Michael J. Bayly, an Australian who resides in the US and who served as the executive coordinator of the Catholic Pastoral Committee on Sexual Minorities (CPCSM) from 2003-2015. This blog has been churning out posts since 2006(!), with the most recent post being about Lil Nas X coming out. Lots of older posts review books, talk about queer Saints, and more.
Remembering that there are countless Catholics on your side can be a huge encouragement when facing fears that God doesn’t accept you. You are supported, you are loved, and you don’t have to choose between embracing your whole self & being Catholic.
_____
Is there even a hell at all??
It may help you to start rephrasing ideas around hell, and to explore alternative conceptions of heaven and hell in the Christian community.
- Instead of thinking of hell as a place God “sends” “bad people,” many Christians (including a lot of Catholics) conceive of hell as a place some people choose to go — “hell’s door is locked from the inside” — the only way to “end up” in hell is to say no to God’s freely offered gift of heaven.
- Meanwhile, Orthodox tradition holds that heaven and hell are the same “place” — we all end up in the unfiltered presence of God, but to evil people that Presence is agony.
- And there are some Christians (myself included) who don’t think hell exists at all! (or at least that very few, if any, people end up there.)
Some posts that might help you explore conceptions of hell that don’t lead to being frozen in fear:
______
In closing
Dear anon, you are a beloved child of God. God made you gay, God made you trans, and most simply, God made you — not for suffering, not for fear, but for the purpose of loving and being loved by God.
When it’s hard for you to remember that…
- Check out those previously linked organizations for a reminder of how many Catholics are in your corner
- Wander through my #queer and Catholic tag for a reminder that you’re not the only LGBT Catholic; or my #affirmation tag; or my trans Jesus or God beyond gender tags…
- Reach out to someone you can trust; or take some time to sit quietly with God, asking that They enfold you in their love.
I wish you the best, anon. This kind of fear is hard to shake, but even in the midst of it, you are deeply and eternally loved. Hang in there <3