ONE SPIRIT, MANY GIFTS (Posts tagged antisemitism)

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna
a-queer-seminarian

Anonymous asked:

So I have a somewhat technical theological question for you based on a post I saw recently (I think it was one of yours or you'd commented, but not 100% sure) and am hoping for your insight on it. On the post I'm thinking of, it was mentioned that in some denominations of Christianity, Judaism is seen as a sister religion that is still valid by God, as he has kept his promise to the Jewish people. I've also encountered the idea that Jews will get a "second chance" to convert during the end times. Would this still apply to a Jew by choice who was baptized and raised Christian? Or would that person be considered an apostate/be seen as having turned their back on Jesus and salvation?

a-queer-seminarian answered:

Hey there, anon! Thank you for the question. Sorry my response is long lol, but this is a complex and extremely important topic!

Also, for future reference for you and others, I prefer to receive any asks that aren’t specifically about me or seminary stuff over on my broader blog, @blessedarethebinarybreakers.

____

I do indeed have a post over on my other blog about how Jewish people already have a completely fulfilling relationship with God.

That viewpoint is completely contrary to the other one that you bring up — that at the End Times, Jews will have a “second chance” to convert. That viewpoint is all too common in Christianity, and it causes real harm to Jewish people here and now.

  • In this viewpoint, back in Gospel times, the Jewish people rejected Jesus as their messiah. In this viewpoint, Jewish scriptures — what Christians unfortunately dub the “Old Testament” — foretell Jesus as the messiah, so in “rejecting him,” basically they’ve completely misread their own scriptures.
  • …To tell a people group they have their own scripture wrong is…condescending, to say the least.
  • Another problem with this viewpoint is that in order for the Jewish people to “reject” Jesus as messiah, they’d have to have considered him a contender in the first place…and they didn’t! Jesus just isn’t relevant to Judaism.
  • This is a bad comparison (because Hindus in my cultural context at least don’t go around doing this kind of thing the way Christians do lol), but to try to help make the point, if say, a Hindu told me I’ve rejected Shiva, I’d be like…I haven’t? Shiva’s just not relevant to my life. How can I have rejected a deity that I’ve barely contemplated??

Many Christians who believe that all Jews (and/or all non-Christians) will have a last chance to convert to Christianity / accept Jesus as Lord etc. genuinely believe that this is a kind and respectful viewpoint. I used to think so, too! It’s only been through listening to Jewish persons and other non-Christians that I’ve come to understand how it perpetuates Christian supremacy (after all, it implies that Christianity is supreme, that all good people should and will one day become Christian).

So yeah, TL;DR: the Jewish people can’t have a “second chance” to become Christian because, 1) there was no “first chance,” no time the whole Jewish people “rejected” Jesus and/or Christianity; and 2) they don’t need a “second chance,” since they already have a valid and fulfilling relationship with the Divine.

_____

Finally, to answer the last bit of your question about the End Time fate of someone baptized & raised Christian and converted to Judaism:

I totally understand if you are worried about that either for yourself or someone else in your life. The Christian supremacist ideas about who "needs” that kind of “second chance” are deeply ingrained in a lot of us, and take a long time to fully unpack! So whatever your beliefs are, current or future, about the End Times and heaven and all of that, I hope you can find comfort in this:

God’s compassion is infinite, beyond any human compassion. If you or I as human beings could imagine having mercy on such a person, so much more for God!

A lot of Christians, especially white evangelical Christians, put a lot of their focus on the End Times and the world to come — but if you take some time to revisit Jesus’s own ministry, you’ll notice how little he brings up the world to come. He’s much more focused on bringing liberation here and now. Same goes for the prophets before him, from Moses to Amos to Isaiah. God’s will is for our flourishing here and now — on earth as it is in heaven.

So as far as possible, I believe it’s often most fruitful to put aside end time talk and thoughts about some abstract afterlife — to pay more attention to what’s going on right now, in your little corner of this beautiful planet. What injustices would Esther, Jeremiah, Jesus be calling out? Who are the mighty who need to be cast down from their thrones, who are the oppressed in need of empowerment, and how can I, you, we participate in that? That’s where our focus needs to be. When it comes to what comes next, we can rely on the compassion of the God who created us not for suffering, but for flourishing, not for punishment, but restoration.

____

Further Reading:

long post essays antisemitism issues in christianity

‘Marcion, an early church theologian active in the first part of the second century, taught that the God of the Old Testament, typified by wrath, was distinct from the loving God of the New. …As a professor of biblical studies, I know that his legacy continues.

This year in particular, I have found some blog posts of this semester’s students surprising and unsettling, even upsetting.  I am co-teaching a course called “Scripture”… In the posts for one of the first classes, several students commented on the OT’s angry God — their language — highlighting a small selection of texts that they had read, such as the conquest of the land of Israel by Joshua. But none of these students balanced this presentation with other texts that they also knew, such as the book of Jonah, whose very theme is God’s compassion for all. 

At the beginning of the next class, I called out this problem, and even showed the entire class a website, which, using principles as selective as Marcion, highlights the loving God of the OT and the fierce and vengeful God of the New. …It starts with this contrast: 

God [in the Hebrew Bible / Old Testament] is compassionate and slow to anger: “The Lord, the Lord, the compassionate and gracious God, slow to anger, abounding in love and faithfulness” (Exodus 34:6) vs. Jesus says he has come to sow violence: ‘Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth; I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; and one’s foes will be members of one’s own household.’ (Mt 10: 34-39). 

It continues with a series of similar contrasts, and should be shown by all teachers of the Bible in one of the first classes. This post by Notre Dame’s Gary Anderson is also very helpful.  …’

- Marc Zvi Brettler

______

Further reading:

  • This quote by Amy-Jill Levine about the God of love and anger is pertinent to this conversation: 
    .
    “[A common error Christian preachers make when they talk about the Judaism of Jesus’ day is] that Jews believe in a God of wrath and Christianity invented the God of love. When I get that from my students I’m inclined to tell them, ‘Fine, the Lord is my shepherd, his mercy endures forever, but you’re condemned to the outer darkness with wailing and gnashing of teeth.’
    .
    God is a God of love throughout both testaments… but God is not a ‘don’t worry, be happy’ sort of deity. We have certain responsibilities. When we do not show the love of neighbor that Leviticus commands us and that Jesus reiterates, God has good old righteous anger.”
    .
  • An old post of mine that goes into Marcionism at length
  • This scholarly article on Marcionism in Christian preaching & how to combat it
  • Post about supersessionism and how to uproot it in your own beliefs (supersessionism = the idea that Christians have “superseded” Jews as “God’s People” & that Christianity makes Judaism irrelevant / replaces Judaism)
  • Response to a person asking whether Christianity is inherently antisemitic, with links to resources for recognizing and uprooting antisemitism in your beliefs & faith communities 
  • My tag about pharisees and how they get a bad rep
supersessionism marcionism antisemitism issues in christianity article quote tag marcion reading and studying the bible bible tag

Anonymous asked:

My faith is really important to me. But based off of what I’ve seen some Jewish people say about Christianity, the Gospels, and Jesus, I’m starting to feel like practicing my faith is inherently antiSemitic and I don’t know how to navigate that. For ex. I saw a Jewish creator say Jesus flipping everything in the temple was antisemitic propaganda as Christianity was starting to separate from Judaism so Christians should stop celebrating that story. How much of the faith reflects this? Can we be actually Christian without upholding antisemitism? It’s giving me a lot of stress and I’m interested in hearing your thoughts.

This ask really resonates me. I strive to be in true solidarity with Jewish communities and for me, a lot of that looks like calling out antisemitism within the Christian communities to which I belong – because even the most progressive Christian communities tend to have antisemitism down deep in their bones.

Still, I firmly believe it is possible to be Christian while actively rejecting and combatting antisemitism. And the first step to that is acknowledging and dealing with the antisemitism that’s been baked into our religion since the time our scriptures were written, through a horrific history of pogroms and blood libel, and into the present day. It sounds like you are on your way already, anon – keep on following that urge to discover how to be Christian without perpetuating antisemitism!

If you go through my #antisemitism tag here (and also on my other blog, @a-queer-seminarian), you’ll find lots of information and further resources on our antisemitic history and present and how to deal with it. I recommend this post to start with. For instance, it’s got stuff about that table-flipping story that I think you’ll find helpful – because yes, it is very often interpreted in horribly antisemitic ways. Progressive Christians in particular are often guilty of uplifting the table-flipping story without addressing that antisemitism.

Some of the stuff you’ll find in my antisemitism and that you’ll want to educate yourself more about are the concepts of “supersessionism,” “philosemitism,” and Pharisees as Pretty Cool, Actually.

Overall, the works of Jewish scholar Amy-Jill Levine have been the most helpful to me – any book or lecture by her is sure to help you out. She is a Jewish woman who believes that the message of Jesus is worthwhile, and that means a lot to me. If she who has faced antisemitism from Christians firsthand still finds something worthwhile in Jesus, then I can, too.

Another voice I deeply respect is that of Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg, who is very active on Twitter.

If anyone has resources about fighting antisemitism as a Christian that they have found particularly helpful, please do share.

antisemitism issues in christianity

Anonymous asked:

I'm not sure if this blog or your other blog is more appropriate than this. I was raised in a branch of Christianity that is very supersessionist (for your followers who may not know, that's the belief that the new covenant in Jesus has replaced God's relationship with the Jewish people and the Mosaic laws). I'm aware of the antisemitism that often stems from this interpretation, and I was wondering what other alternative interpretations are?

Hey yes hi, confronting antisemitism within Christianity is a deep passion of mine. Good on you for beginning the long work of uprooting supersessionist beliefs within yourself!

In short, alternatives to supersessionist views of Christianity and Judaism is to hold that

  1. Jesus didn’t replace the torah, and Christianity didn’t “replace” Judaism – Jesus cherished the torah and other Jewish writings as his own, letting them nourish and fuel his own ministry; and Christianity and Judaism are related but distinct religions that both faithfully relate to God; and
  2. God’s covenant with Christians doesn’t replace God’s covenant with the Jewish people – both covenants are particular to particular communities, and can exist at the same time.

The rest of this post offers resources for learning and understanding these things.

My favorite resources on antisemitism and supersessionism within Christianity come from Amy-Jill Levine, a Jewish professor who has dedicated much of her career to Christian-Jewish relationships. The core of what she hopes to teach Christians is this:

“Christian teaching need not malign Jewish tradition in order to make Jesus look good. I’m a Jew. I don’t worship Jesus as lord and savior, but I have spent my life studying him and being inspired by him and learning from him. He’s a splendid teacher! If I can see how profound and provocative he is without having to malign Judaism, surely Christians can do the same.”

Stuff from Levine:

Other resources:

As you study, let me know if you have any further specific questions!

Anyone else have recommendations for resources on alternatives to supersessionist thinking?

antisemitism supersessionism issues in christianity
madmaudlingoes
onebiguniondaily

People say “Judeo-Christian” when they mean “Christian, specifically” but they feel like throwing in a little irrelevant antisemitism just to be random

sweetsweetemo

I’ve been trying to understand this post but I can’t, can someone explain this to me?

I believe this person knows what they’re talking about I just don’t get it

werewolfbneimitzvah

Basically, there’s no good reason to use Judeo-Christian to describe anything except maybe a person raised in an interfaith household of those two religions. When people use Judeo-Christian they pretty much always are using it in one of two ways: to talk about something that applies only to Christianity (example I’ve seen: “Judeo-Christian concept of Hell,” which doesn’t exist in Judaism), or using it to talk about something that doesn’t only apply to Judaism and Christianity and also applies to other religions with some source material in common (which all of us then proceed to interpret very differently anyway).

So, it’s pretty much always being used either by someone who thinks they’re talking about a belief of ours but they’re at best ignorant and at worst bigoted (depends on the intentions).

Or it’s being used on purpose by Christians who are trying to use us as a shield, because if they can get us associated with each other then they can call it antisemitic if there’s criticism of them of whatever they’re talking about.

So yeah, in simpler terms it’s used by people who either know better than to use it but are using it anyway (bad) or don’t know better than to use it but are talking with confidence and authority about something as potentially serious and personal as religion/culture that they don’t know anything about (also bad).

Does that help?

sweetsweetemo

ooh, ok

now it makes sense why people were saying it was made to exclude Islamic faith, from what I got, there’s no way to use it that isn’t exclusive or ignorant.

it did help, I think i get it now. thank you for the patience

werewolfbneimitzvah

for sure! mutual of mine also made a point i hadn’t thought about here, about the potential harm that could come from implying that we’re a larger/more influential group than we are by associating us with Christianity.

no worries, have a good day & thank you for listening!

queeranarchism

All of this is very accurate and important.

An addition:

A lot of people on the right an far-right also use ‘Judeo-Christian’ as code for ‘not Muslim’. When a politician says some bullshit like ‘We are a Judeo-Christian culture’, they don’t mean ‘we value the heritage of Jewish people’ (they don’t, see all the above), they mean ‘we’re a culture in which there is no place for Islam’. 

So the concept of ‘Judeo-Christian’ is both antisemitism and islamophobia, as so many things said on the right and far-right are.

always worth reiterating judeo christian antisemitism islamophobia judaism
a-queer-seminarian
a-queer-seminarian:
“[ID: banners read Combatting Antisemitism on Good Friday: Rejecting & Replacing the “Solemn Reproaches of the Cross” - listen on Blessed Are the Binary Breakers, a multifaith podcast of trans stories. A quote from Elizabeth...
a-queer-seminarian

[ID: banners read Combatting Antisemitism  on Good Friday: Rejecting & Replacing  the “Solemn Reproaches of the Cross” - listen on Blessed Are the Binary Breakers, a multifaith podcast of trans stories. A quote from Elizabeth Palmer reads, “Many times over the centuries, in many places, Christians bowed before the cross on Good Friday and heard or sang some version of these words: ‘I led thee through the wilderness 40 years, fed thee with manna, & brought thee into a land exceeding good, & thou hast prepared a cross for thy Savior.’ Then they’d leave the church, form a mob, and attack Jewish communities.” end id]

_____________

A quick impromptu episode of Blessed Are the Binary Breakers focuses on the history of antisemitism on Good Friday, with the direct example of an alternative liturgy to the “Solemn Reproaches of the Cross.”

The “Reproaches” are coated in the blood of our Jewish neighbors. They should not be read or sung in our worship — but neither can we pretend this text never existed. I draw from Professor Amy-Jill Levine’s advice on this topic: Levine is a Jewish woman who has devoted much of her career to study of the New Testament, and she names “admitting the problem” as the most effective strategy for resolving problematic scripture. Rather than burying this document, we must grapple with it, teach its history to our communities and guide them in dissecting what in the text’s language is so violently antisemitic.

My hope is that the alternative liturgy I wrote to replace and call out the “Reproaches” might serve churches as a jumping off point for conversation. Feedback is welcome, especially from those who listen to the whole episode so they have full context :)

Here’s an excerpt from my alternative text – you can also read it in full here or listen to the full thing / read along in the episode transcript.

I chose the children of Israel as my own…
My covenant with them is eternal.

My Torah instructs them well on how to love me
by loving the stranger, the Other, the defenseless –

Yet you claim your relationship with me negates theirs!

You call their testament “old,”
and claim the God you find there
is bloodthirsty, barbaric, not the same God;

Across the centuries you have listened to the story
Of how I was charged by Roman powers with sedition,
died on a Roman cross,

And then go out and blame “the Jews” for my death!

You have coerced conversion,
enacted or enabled
hate crimes against them;
You have shunned and slandered them,
when you ought to have embraced them as your kin!

When you reject and persecute my Jewish people,
truly, truly you reject and persecute me.

antisemitism good friday issues in christianity podcast liturgy

Confronting our antisemitism during Holy Week

“Jesus of Nazareth, charged by the Roman authorities with sedition, dies on a Roman cross. But Jews ― the collective, all Jews ― become known as “Christ-killers.” Still haunting, the legacy of that charge becomes acute during Holy Week, when pastors and priests who speak about the death of Jesus have to talk about “the Jews.” Every year, the same difficulty surfaces: how can a gospel of love be proclaimed, if that same gospel is heard to promote hatred of Jesus’s own people?”

- Professor Amy-Jill Levine

___________________________

Holy Week is here, so I thought I’d remind myself and other Christians that it is imperative to resist antisemitic interpretations of Jesus’s Passion.

Holy Week has long been a dangerous time of the year for Jewish persons (See this article for the history of antisemitic hate crimes on Good Friday in medieval Europe, for instance). And the scriptures that we choose to read in our churches during this time fuels that antisemitism not only this week, but the whole year round. 

When our Gospels’ various versions of the Passion narrative are full of inflammatory language about “The Jews” shouting “Crucify him!,” about the disciples (despite being Jewish themselves!) hiding away “for fear of the Jews,” it’s no wonder that we absorb an antisemitic message when we read those scriptures every year – especially when we aren’t given any guidance on the context as to why these texts were written this way or what to do about it.

So. How can we acknowledge and combat the antisemitism that has too long been entrenched in our communities?

________________

RESOURCES

First, let’s get educated on the basic facts about antisemitism in Holy Week’s typical scriptures, and alternatives to concluding that “the Jews killed Jesus”:

Next, let’s reimagine the stories we read during Holy Week in ways that don’t do harm to our Jewish neighbors! Replace the bad with good!

This quote from Levine in this article sums up the purpose of her scholarship as a whole:

“A number of Christian commentators feel the need to make Judaism look bad in order to make Jesus look good. Instead of portraying Jesus as a Jew talking to other Jews, he becomes in their views the first Christian, the one who invented divine grace, mercy, and love, and all that other good stuff. Such views neglect the presence of these same virtues within Jesus’ own Jewish context. There should be no reason this Jewish Jesus is used to promote anti-Judaism.”

Finally, if you only have time for one resource, make it this article:

“Holy Week and the hatred of the Jews: How to avoid anti-Judaism this Easter,” also written by Amy-Jill Levine.

  • In this article, Levine describes how the anti-Jewish language got into the Gospels to begin with; how interfaith conversations today help stem the tide of antisemitism; and explores and ranks the 6 strategies Levine has seen people use when trying to resolve these problems with the New Testament.
    .
  • From least useful to most useful, she names these strategies as excision (just removing the problematic stuff and pretending it was never there); retranslation (changing up the way we translate problematic texts, such as changing “the Jews” to “Judeans”); romanticizing (this includes Christians holding their own Passover seders – read this part of the article to see why we should Not Do That); allegorizing; historicizing; and, best of all, just admitting the problem:

“We come finally to our sixth option: admit to the problem and deal with it. There are many ways congregations can address the difficult texts. Put a note in service bulletins to explain the harm the texts have caused. Read the problematic texts silently, or in a whisper. Have Jews today give testimony about how they have been hurt by the texts.

Those who proclaim the problematic verses from the pulpit might imagine a Jewish child sitting in the front pew and take heed: don’t say anything that would hurt this child, and don’t say anything that would cause a member of the congregation to hurt this child.

Better still: educate the next generation, so that when they hear the problematic words proclaimed, they have multiple contexts - theological, historical, ethical - by which to understand them.

Christians, hearing the Gospels during Holy Week, should no more hear a message of hatred of Jews than Jews, reading the Book of Esther on Purim, should hate Persians, or celebrating the seder and reliving the time when “we were slaves in Egypt,” should hate Egyptians.

We choose how to read. After two thousand years of enmity, Jews and Christians today can recover and even celebrate our common past, locate Jesus and his earliest followers within rather than over and against Judaism, and live into the time when, as both synagogue and church proclaim, we can love G-d and our neighbour.’

___________

What do you think? 

Do you have more questions you’re wrestling with? more ideas on how to actually deal with our antisemitism, in Holy Week and beyond? more resources on this topic you’d like to share?

antisemitism passion narratives holy week passion of christ issues in christianity
that-love-is-all-there-is
idkinsertfanreferencehere

HEY VATICAN GIVE US OUR STUFF BACK


(I’m looking through the archive and I cannot count on my fingers how many of these documents are ones that I learned were “lost to history” and that we “don’t have early manuscripts of” or are “missing the questions to the responsa” and we’re not! They’re not! The Vatican has them!)

sorekbekarmi

I assumed this was going to be about the Menorah

But it was worse, somehow

idkinsertfanreferencehere

Yeah, I mean there are the originals of Gaonic responsa literature, copies of rashi’s commentary dated to the century he lived in, Babylonian Talmud pages from before the 10th century, richly illustrated prayer books and tehillim that are dated and placed to inquisition-era Spain but sure as hell don’t mention the fact that they were looted off of the people the church murdered, a Sefer Torah from the 12TH CENTURY, just. So much. So much and they have no right to any of it.

idkinsertfanreferencehere

no you know what I’m not done. We have been begging for hundreds of years, politely, academically, kindly, for the Vatican to return what it stole. Or if not that, to allow for Jewish scholars to have access to their archives (the number of questions and arguments that resulted from divergent manuscripts later in history that these documents could solve!) or if not that then at least acknowledge that fact that these documents were at best stolen, most likely looted, and at worst taken at swordpoint and killed for, and they refuse. They refuse to do even that.

fromchaostocosmos

i would also like to point out that any projects funded by the vatican during specific centuries were only possible because the vatican looted and stole from us or by enforcing special taxes that were just for Jewish people only

they did this in the sanctioning of state expulsions which members of the clergy helped the state by over seeing that Jewish people left because you had clergy members all through out the country

and as the oversee this the process they would go through Jewish people’s belonging and steal: what limited amounts money we had (because despite what you think most Jewish people for most of our history in Diaspora lived in poverty), stealing religious items like what is listed above, stealing anything that might could it made out gold, silver, or had value, but could be melted down so if you had silver kiddish cup it was taken and would get melted down to be used for something else that need silver 

all of these stolen items be compiled together with a large cut going of anything of monetary value going to the state which is why they did this a lot and the rest going to the vatican to be used at their desecration

if you look at history often after the expulsions those countries end up doing very financially poorly and if look at what is going on right before the expulsions there is ramping up of antisemitism as well as mismanagement of state funds, the government in need of funds (usually an increase of taxes which makes the people angry) so the government goes for the tried and true method of get rid of the Jewish people who they hate and will get them good PR with the people while also getting free funds by stealing from said Jewish people

the other method it the special tax method: so most countries in Europe (and Russia) when Jewish people were not expelled had essentially a Jew tax which basically was added on tax to any other taxes that were being paid that were for Jewish people only to pay. The amount of money to would vary with no rhyme or reason and it was depend of the mood of who ever was in charge or if they needed more money that month or if they felt like being an asshole

the tax was charged on towns and ghettos not really rather then normal taxes where it goes by person

the government would take most of this money, but it was expected to give a cut of it to the vatican

so when you go to Europe and you see these stunning churches that feats of architect and artworks like say the notre dame (which was funded by the vatican) if it was funded by the vatican it was funded with stolen blood money

(also a huge amount of same churches will also be have built on Jewish bones because they were built using Jewish slaves so another fun fact for and within the design is often lots of very antisemitic imagery to add icing onto the shit cake for us Jewish people)

anyways i’m totally up for showing up to vatican and just taking us stuff back if anyone wants to go (like if you american like me when we can actually travel again) cause fuck the vatican and fuck every single pope ever

hypatiasblood

I went on a European educational tour trip thing last year and I ended up in Spain going to the monastery in Montserrat. Wanting to avoid the seventeen thousandth church I’d been dragged to (seriously so frickin many) I took a tour of their art museum. And in there I found these.

image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image

They aren’t even fucking hiding the shit they stole from us. I was so annoyed.

brunhiddensmusings

given that was spain it wasnt just stolen, it was stolen AFTER torture

random2908

My parents went on a vacation to Spain a few years ago with my middle sister, and they went to a ton of museums. My mom had PTSD for six months just from the museum exhibits. All our stuff on display, captioned with reminders that they eradicated us, all implying that Jews were an extinct people*. Apparently in Spain what they’ve done with stolen Jewish artwork and property is when Jews have asked for any of it back, they nationalized it and put it in museums so that it would be illegal, under Spanish law, to give any of it back. This has been a 20th/21st century tactic, by the way–it was the result of renewed scrutiny because stuff looted from the Holocaust somehow made its way into Spain (because Spain welcomed fleeing Nazi officers), although they applied it to stuff they directly looted in the Inquisition too, of course.

the-home-kvetch

Lemme add that the Vatican stole Jewish children and has never owned up to this.

During the Holocaust, numerous Catholic families, organized by the Church, took Jewish children in (and sometimes the children of other groups, but that was rarer). The families raised these kids as their own. Many children were raised in church convents as orphans– where they were baptized and given Christian names.

After the war was over, survivors would return to the church or the priest and ask for their kids back. They always claimed that the Church never had Jewish children and never placed them with other families. Families were not told where the children were placed or even if the children were alive. Parents who thought their children were being kept safe lost them all over again.

There are thousands of children who were raised not knowing their parentage or religion and have no idea who they really are.


I will never forgive the Catholic Church for what it did to us.

antisemitism vatican long post history museums issues in christianity

“Granted Pharisees do get some bad press in the Gospels, but that’s because they represented a viable alternative to the messianic proclamation of Jesus and his followers. Pharisees were a lay-led movement whose members were known for walking the walk as well as talking the talk, and for interpreting the Torah to make it more egalitarian – for showing the people how they could be like priests in the temple, and how they could make their meals comparable to the sacrifices in the temple.
…
Christian teaching need not malign Jewish tradition in order to make Jesus look good. I’m a Jew. I don’t worship Jesus as lord and savior, but I have spent my life studying him and being inspired by him and learning from him. He’s a splendid teacher! If I can see how profound and provocative he is without having to malign Judaism, surely Christians can do the same.”

- Amy-Jill Levine in a sermon on March 7, 2021

amy jill levine antisemitism pharisees issues in christianity sermons reading and studying the Bible quote tag fave
trumpetvineappreciator
creekfiend

A friend of mine from around here who is Very Christian and has never had a Jewish friend before was asking me some stuff about antisemitism today, and it made me realize that the ways people talk about various types of bigotry and racism are so designed to stump people about the nature and purpose of systems of oppression. "Why do people hate the jews so much?" is such a common refrain and while there have been many books and articles written pulling apart all the important contextual and historical things that can help people understand antisemitism SPECIFICALLY, what I ended up saying to my friend was this:

"Something to understand about antisemitism is it isnt just ideological. The expulsion of jews from various countries was very often a method of "legally" seizing their wealth when the church needed money. It has been historically an incredibly convenient source of both a group of people to blame and also an easy way to just... Be able to steal from people, lmao. It has served very concrete material purposes for churches and governments throughout history. Sometimes you have to approach asking those questions from a different angle because it often isnt about the hatred so much as it is about ... Redirecting energy and attention, right, like upholding structures that benefit those in power. The hatred is convenient because it allows those in power to take actions that would not be tolerated if the group in question were not considered to be Exceptional in their inhumanity. Like the undocumented immigrants now, asking "why do they hate the immigrants so much" isnt always a productive avenue of thought because the hatred is usually just... Useful. Rather it is more helpful to ask "Who does it benefit for these people to be treated this way" -> "what do they need to make the general public believe about that group of people in order to justify this treatment". I think sometimes we are made to think hatred of jews is special and rooted in something different than other hatred... It's not. I mean all types of racism etc are unique. But it very much is about justifying actions that benefit a ruling class in all instances, imo."

And she like totally got it!!! She was like "OH I NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT IT LIKE THAT BUT THAT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE THANK YOU" I am very proud of myself lol :')

important antisemitism anti semitism oppression hatred
a-queer-seminarian
a-queer-seminarian

images are of a twitter thread by Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg @TheRaDR from Feb 8, 2019. The first tweet responds to another person’s tweet that reads, “I sometimes think that Jesus wouldn’t recognize Evangelical Christianity in America. Then I realize he would recognize it perfectly well—as exactly the polluted, sick, predatory, power-hungry, hypocritical thing he spent his life opposing.”

Rabbi Ruttenberg’s response is, “So, if you mean as Empire, I’m with you. But I see a lot of replies using the word “Pharisees,” which a) weren’t Jesus’ opponent, he *was* a Pharisee having intra-communal debates w/his own people and b) if that’s what was meant, it’s an antisemitic dog whistle!”

The thread continues, “The Pharisees were the ancestors to Rabbinic Judaism-what we do now. Jesus was a Jew arguing with his fellow Jews about the future of Judaism and that word has been used to murder & expel us for centuries–Inquisitions, pogroms, expulsions, the Holocaust, you name it.

Can you hear the diff bw me (a Conservative rabbi) critiquing something in the Conservative movement & an Orthodox Jew saying that Conservative Jews aren’t valid? Or of a Christian person saying that all Jews, are bad? Jesus re: Pharisees was most analogous to the 1st of those.

And in addition to being inaccurate, when you use it as an insult you reinforce antisemitism. Like how kids saying “that’s so gay” is a problem viz homophobia even if they don’t directly intend it that way. Also, when people use “Pharisee” to describe what someone horrible is doing, it implies that Jewish law somehow condones that thing (since Rabbinic Judaism came from the Pharisaic tradition historically). And I will tell you, in the cases I’ve see it used? Jewish law does NOT.

Also ironically a Christian telling someone they suck because they are being a Pharisee has the added bonus of potentially insulting a Pharisee they hope to emulate.

Now, if you can’t see how Jews throughout history have been painted by Christians as being “polluted, sick, predatory, power-hungry, hypocritical” then you need to learn something more about history. Which is why the original tweet concerns me. Hate crimes against Jews are up.  By 37%, according to the FBI in November. They’re up across the board, yes, but only by 17%.  There is a disproportionate rise in antisemitism.  We make up only 1.4% of the US population. Our synagogues and even offices are being covered with swastikas. People are beating us up in the street.  Our graveyards are being desecrated. There was a massacre in synagogue.  Inflammatory rhetoric and dog whistles contribute to this climate.

So, you really really really really have to learn a lot about halakha before you make this tired old misleading point that, yes, has been also used to bolster antisemitism.

/ end id

____

the thread continues with links to more twitter threads by Rabbi Ruttenberg – a thread with a contemporary example of antisemitism; a thread on Jewish law; and a thread on what Jesus was critiquing in his arguments with other Pharisees.

antisemitism anti semitism
a-queer-seminarian
a-queer-seminarian

Full thread continues below the ID.

Image is the beginning of a twitter thread by Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg @TheRaDR from Feb 10, 2019, reading,

OK, this here is a thread on Jewish law.  1/x For everybody, but I’ll start with a question for my Christian friends: If someone was like, hey, I have a Diet Coke and some Oreos, that’ll do for communion, right? Most of you’d probably come back with a pretty strong no, right?

That’s because Communion is a particular thing, and not everything or anything will get you there. The fact that it’s bread and wine matters. & different Christian communities might have different takes on whether the bread can be a baguette or whether it must be a wafer or etc. And maybe those discussions are spirited or maybe it’s like THIS IS WHAT WE DO DON’T ASK QUESTIONS but the idea is that this encounter with the holy has to happen in a certain way for it to work–for the proverbial engine to go on, for the ritual to do its ritual magic, yes?

Got that? OK. Don’t ever call Jews legalistic again.  Don’t ever suggest that having an investment in the how it happens is pedantic or dry.  For us, it’s not pedantic at all.  It’s passionate and invested and spirited and joyful.

/ end ID. Continuation of the thread:

Jewish law is meant to impact just about every aspect of our lives, but not in a harsh or limiting way.  In a, things matter and have consequence sort of way.  In a, here are more opportunities to connect with the holy, sort of way.

You know how contemporary mindfulness language says you should strive to be fully present when you’re doing the dishes and chopping the carrots and walking to work?

“You shall love God your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might. Take to heart these instructions with which I charge you this day. Impress them upon your children. Recite them when you stay at home and when you are away, when you lie down and when you get up. Bind them as a sign on your hand and make them frontlets between yr eyes; inscribe them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates.” (Deuteronomy 6).  Jewish law encircles our lives.  It encourages us to strive for that connection.

(“Our” “us” – Jews who live inside this system, not all Jews do, there are lots of philosophies of halakha–Jewish law, literally “the going/the path” and ways to relate to it, I’m speaking broadly-ish here, Yidden, adapt as feels useful.)

We have centuries of passionate engagement around how to live out the details of service to the divine because the details matter.  Because “oh, I’m sure whatever is fine” is not, this approach suggests, not how you serve God. Doing it right matters.  But we also know that there are a multiplicity of ways to do it right, or we honor, often, the multiplicity of perspectives.   The Talmud records 5000 disagreements about whether X is kosher or not or whatever and only 50 are resolved on the page.

The Shulchan Aruch–one of our most important law codes–literally has Yosef Caro, the main author, a refugee from the Spanish expulsion who wound up in the Land of Israel going, “You should do X and Y thing” and the Rema, the author of the Ashkenazi commentary, right after it, going, “Uh, that’s not how we do things here.  Around here, this is the deal.”  So you open up the Shulchan Aruch and you see those two voices, one after the other, same paragraph of text, in different fonts so you know who’s talking. We sacralize the conversation.

Understand, also, how radical and democratic this is.  The Pharisees (the ancestors of Rabbinic Judaism) pushing for living out service to God in all of our day to day lives ran in stark contrast to the Temple-focused Saducees.

Temple focus means only ppl of priestly descent can work in the Temple/be eligible for High Priest/etc, privileges Jerusalem and those near it, privileges those who have $$ for big sacrifices, etc. Whereas everyone can light the Shabbat lamp.  Everyone can pray.

[The thread actually continues further, with Rabbi Ruttenberg discussing how halakha and observing mitzvot have enriched her life. It’s beautiful stuff; go check out her thread to read it!]

i love this thread so much judaism legalism anti semitism antisemitism
progressivejudaism

Anonymous asked:

What are your thoughts on messianic Judaism? And what are your thoughts of those who convert ?

progressivejudaism answered:

Hi there,

Thank you so much for writing to me on such an important topic.

Messianic Judaism is a form of Christianity.  In my opinion, it is a dangerous appropriation of Judaism.  For the past nearly 2000 years, the Jewish people have been subject to persecutions.  In many of these periods, these persecutions were due to the fact that the Jewish people had no theological relationship with Jesus.

Although some Messianic Jews might be biologically Jewish, they worship Jesus.  Worshiping Jesus is not Judaism, but Christianity.  The Jewish concept of the Messiah can be complicated, but we all agree that Jesus is not a part of this equation.

I really do not have any thoughts about those interested in converting in this direction, other than I suggest thinking about converting to a different Christian faith tradition.

If you would like to chat more, please feel free to send me a private message.  I’d love to chat!

PJ

messianic judaism antisemitism