Anonymous asked:
So I have a somewhat technical theological question for you based on a post I saw recently (I think it was one of yours or you'd commented, but not 100% sure) and am hoping for your insight on it. On the post I'm thinking of, it was mentioned that in some denominations of Christianity, Judaism is seen as a sister religion that is still valid by God, as he has kept his promise to the Jewish people. I've also encountered the idea that Jews will get a "second chance" to convert during the end times. Would this still apply to a Jew by choice who was baptized and raised Christian? Or would that person be considered an apostate/be seen as having turned their back on Jesus and salvation?
a-queer-seminarian answered:
Hey there, anon! Thank you for the question. Sorry my response is long lol, but this is a complex and extremely important topic!
Also, for future reference for you and others, I prefer to receive any asks that aren’t specifically about me or seminary stuff over on my broader blog, @blessedarethebinarybreakers.
____
I do indeed have a post over on my other blog about how Jewish people already have a completely fulfilling relationship with God.
- This viewpoint is one I have learned from Christians who seek interfaith relationship with Jewish persons.
- For instance, Barabara Brown Taylor expounds upon it in her book Holy Envy: Finding God in the Faith of Others, which I highly recommend for Christians who are seeking to understand how to respect persons of other faiths while being committed to their own. I’ve got a tag with passages from Holy Envy that you can start out with to see if you’re interested in the whole book :)
- I’ve also been deeply enriched by the perspectives of Jewish persons like New Testament scholar Amy Jill Levine — I have tons of passages from her here — and Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg, whom you should totally follow if you have a Twitter. (See also the couple of great threads from her I’ve shared here on tumblr)
That viewpoint is completely contrary to the other one that you bring up — that at the End Times, Jews will have a “second chance” to convert. That viewpoint is all too common in Christianity, and it causes real harm to Jewish people here and now.
- In this viewpoint, back in Gospel times, the Jewish people rejected Jesus as their messiah. In this viewpoint, Jewish scriptures — what Christians unfortunately dub the “Old Testament” — foretell Jesus as the messiah, so in “rejecting him,” basically they’ve completely misread their own scriptures.
- …To tell a people group they have their own scripture wrong is…condescending, to say the least.
- Another problem with this viewpoint is that in order for the Jewish people to “reject” Jesus as messiah, they’d have to have considered him a contender in the first place…and they didn’t! Jesus just isn’t relevant to Judaism.
- This is a bad comparison (because Hindus in my cultural context at least don’t go around doing this kind of thing the way Christians do lol), but to try to help make the point, if say, a Hindu told me I’ve rejected Shiva, I’d be like…I haven’t? Shiva’s just not relevant to my life. How can I have rejected a deity that I’ve barely contemplated??
Many Christians who believe that all Jews (and/or all non-Christians) will have a last chance to convert to Christianity / accept Jesus as Lord etc. genuinely believe that this is a kind and respectful viewpoint. I used to think so, too! It’s only been through listening to Jewish persons and other non-Christians that I’ve come to understand how it perpetuates Christian supremacy (after all, it implies that Christianity is supreme, that all good people should and will one day become Christian).
- An extreme version of this viewpoint that’s common in white evangelicalism is that a widespread conversion of Jews is one of the signs (or catalysts?) of the End Times. These Christians make converting Jewish people a priority. Historically, this has brought horrific violence upon Jewish communities, and that continues to this day.
So yeah, TL;DR: the Jewish people can’t have a “second chance” to become Christian because, 1) there was no “first chance,” no time the whole Jewish people “rejected” Jesus and/or Christianity; and 2) they don’t need a “second chance,” since they already have a valid and fulfilling relationship with the Divine.
_____
Finally, to answer the last bit of your question about the End Time fate of someone baptized & raised Christian and converted to Judaism:
I totally understand if you are worried about that either for yourself or someone else in your life. The Christian supremacist ideas about who "needs” that kind of “second chance” are deeply ingrained in a lot of us, and take a long time to fully unpack! So whatever your beliefs are, current or future, about the End Times and heaven and all of that, I hope you can find comfort in this:
God’s compassion is infinite, beyond any human compassion. If you or I as human beings could imagine having mercy on such a person, so much more for God!
A lot of Christians, especially white evangelical Christians, put a lot of their focus on the End Times and the world to come — but if you take some time to revisit Jesus’s own ministry, you’ll notice how little he brings up the world to come. He’s much more focused on bringing liberation here and now. Same goes for the prophets before him, from Moses to Amos to Isaiah. God’s will is for our flourishing here and now — on earth as it is in heaven.
So as far as possible, I believe it’s often most fruitful to put aside end time talk and thoughts about some abstract afterlife — to pay more attention to what’s going on right now, in your little corner of this beautiful planet. What injustices would Esther, Jeremiah, Jesus be calling out? Who are the mighty who need to be cast down from their thrones, who are the oppressed in need of empowerment, and how can I, you, we participate in that? That’s where our focus needs to be. When it comes to what comes next, we can rely on the compassion of the God who created us not for suffering, but for flourishing, not for punishment, but restoration.
____
Further Reading:
- Reminder about the Holy Envy book quotes on respecting non-Christians
- And again with the Amy Jill Levine quotes link
- My antisemitism tag on my other blog is full of stuff to help Christians recognize where we are failing to love our Jewish neighbors as ourselves. This post in particular is a good starting place.
- And this post is also a good place to start, with ideas for avoiding or uprooting supersessionism (the idea that Judaism was made irrelevant by Christianity) in your Christian beliefs
- A really old post where I talk about the idea of the “end times” a bit more
- I forever love this quote about letting go of both our fear of punishment and desire for reward
- On that topic, here’s my post on why I think the idea of hell is a human idea, not a divine one — and how that ties to the movement for prison abolition here and now
- And here’s my tag for stuff about, like, the afterlife, heaven, hell, etc. in general
- If you’re accustomed to reading the Bible through a lens of “if it’s in the Bible, it’s God’s will,” you might be interested in seeing another framework option.















