Anonymous asked:
I have a question about catholicism. So, my family is from portugal and my grandpa is of course, Catholic. I once had a conversation with him in which he said "we are Catholic" as if I have no choice in it. I have seen a couple of people say that being Catholic is similar to being Jewish because if your family is Catholic you are Catholic by birth. True or false?
Hey! I think different people probably have different opinions about this one. I also may not word this super great so if anyone wants to swoop in and add more info, please do.
First off, I do not think this question of being “born Catholic” is exactly the same as being born Jewish – when that is said of Judaism, it’s about Jewish people as an ethnic group. Catholics are not an ethnic group – rather, we come from a whole bunch of different ethnicities & cultures!
What is going on here, then, is that many times, those cultures have been so influenced by Catholicism that members of the culture may talk of being “__” Catholic (Portuguese Catholic, or Irish Catholic, or Latine Catholic, or Ethiopian Catholic, etc.) as being a culture…in itself?* Something like that.
__________
I think that the question of whether one is Catholic “by birth” or “by choice” is contextual – many of us are born into a Catholic family, who usually get us baptized as infants – and once baptized, we are indeed considered part of the Catholic Church “forever.”
But, Catholicism also offers each person the chance to claim the Catholic faith for themselves once they’ve reached an age at which they can make that choice on their own – that’s why the Sacrament of Confirmation exists (something that in the US at least usually takes place when one’s in 8th grade).
So while your family chose Catholicism for you as an infant, that does not mean you have “no choice in” being Catholic now that you are old enough to choose for yourself – you can say no to embracing Catholicism as a faith.
And you have a choice whether to identify as culturally Catholic as well. You don’t have to claim that identity if you don’t feel like Catholicism is part of your cultural experience. But if you do feel like parts of your culture / how you experience family life has been shaped by Catholicism, calling yourself culturally Catholic makes total sense to me.
According to the Pew Research Center, a good number of people consider themselves Culturally Catholic, even if spiritually they belong to a different or no religion:
“Most of these cultural Catholics (62%) say that for them personally, being Catholic is mainly a matter of ancestry and/or culture (rather than religion). But majorities also point to religious beliefs and teachings as key parts of their Catholic identity. For example, 60% of cultural Catholics say that having a personal relationship with Jesus Christ is essential to what being Catholic means to them. Likewise, 57% say the same about believing in Jesus’ resurrection. A similar share (59%) say that working to help the poor and needy is essential to their Catholicism.”
________________
*To offer a couple examples that show how for a lot of people, culture and Catholicism are pretty tightly intertwined:
- I recently interviewed a Latina Catholic trans woman for my podcast (ep’s not out yet) who talked about how for her, the way she participates in community when she visits her hometown in Peru is largely through Catholic feast days and church events and the like. Even members of the community who aren’t Super Devout participate in these events, because it’s how they connect to the community at large.
. - For another example, there’s my family – we are Irish Catholic in heritage. And as a white middle class US citizen, one reason I really love being Irish Catholic is it is the only bit of my heritage to somewhat survive assimilation into the white American “melting pot.”
I have other ancestors from other countries, but their traditions have not survived into my family today, sadly.
My family – including our atheist / agnostic members – still connects to our Irish heritage through Catholicism: a lot of our names are Irish (tho often “Americanized” versions of the Irish name); we’ve got St. Brigid’s cross (she’s an Irish Saint) above every bedroom door; we celebrate St. Patrick’s Day; when I was a kid we’d sometimes go to Irish dancing events; and at church we would pray and sing Irish hymns, etc.





