This is very true. Seminaries that don’t make an active effort to include marginalized voices in their curricula end up assigning readings that are almost exclusively by white cis male authors. Because almost all the theologians who are considered “standard” and “foundational” are white cis men.
When a (white) woman writes theology, it’s feminist theology. When a Black person writes theology, that’s Black theology. Disabled people write disability theology, trans people write trans theology – so why isn’t there male theology? why isn’t there white theology? – because when white men write theology, it’s just…Theology.
this is not to say that there should not be branches of theology like Black theology and disability theology! These are vital branches and they need to be amplified, not absorbed into the trunk of “general theology.” But we do need to challenge the fact that theology written by abled, cishet white men is the Default – so much the default that it doesn’t get a specifier attached to its label; it’s just Theology. We do need to challenge the fact that the theologies of women, LGBTQA+ persons, immigrants, POC, persons from any non-Western country, disabled persons, and so on aren’t considered “standard” or “foundational” or “must-be-read-to-understand-the-faith.” That their theologies are considered “experiential” and that that’s considered a bad thing – that marginalized persons’ theologies are “subjective” and cishet white men’s theology is “objective.”
The same people who are shoved to the margins and oppressed by our sociopolitical and economic structures are likewise shoved to the margins in our churches, in our seminaries, in our interpretations of scripture. And that’s a huge problem for so many reasons – one being that these are the same persons whom Jesus centered and protected and empowered.
Our religious institutions favor, as Clifford above declares, “male experience, thinking, and values” – the very same experience, thinking, and values that our patriarchal, white supremacist societies favor. According to liberation theology – the “experiential” branch theology that originated in Latin America – God favors the marginalized and oppressed.
Those are the voices that should be centered, not relegated to “optional” volumes of specialized theology while Luther and Calvin and Barth and Rahner alone get to be “foundational” and “must read.” When we are only reading cishet white men’s interpretations of God, we’re only reading the tiniest fragment of how God breathes through all humanity – all are richer when more and more voices are allowed to contribute to the conversation.