Posts Tagged ‘books’

Wrapping up my Shamefully Neglected Reading Blog for 2025

December 14, 2025

The last time I posted a reading update was 21 May when I had finished 29 books. Since then, I’ve read another 19 bringing my annual total to 48, the third consecutive year I didn’t reach 100 and the lowest number since I began tracking my reading in 2008. The biggest factor in the decline seems to be my massively increased interest in 3D printing and miniature wargaming, which consume a much larger proportion of my time. Since May I’ve finished:

Travels with George: In Search of Washington and His Legacy by Nathaniel Philbrick is a travelogue of the author and his wife’s retracing of Washington’s tours of New England and The South at the very beginning of his presidency. I’m afraid this one just didn’t do much for me. There wasn’t enough information about Washington’s experiences nor was there much from the era for the modern-day travels to resonate with. Philbrick’s travels with his wife weren’t particularly interesting either. The highlights of the book all seemed to revolve around the activities and adventures of his dog who accompanied them on most of the trip.

Wellington Against Junot: The First Invasion of Portugal, 1807–1808 by David Buttery was an outstanding book about Junot’s 1807 invasion of Portugal and Wellington’s 1808 counter invasion to turf him out. It is succinct, engaging and well written. I recommend it highly.

Russia Against Napoleon: The True Story of the Campaigns of War and Peace by Dominic Lieven was another outstanding book. This one covers the entirety of Russia’s second war with Napoleon, not only the 1812 invasion, but the 1813 and 1814 campaigns as well. The book is particularly strong on Russian strategic thinking and on her military infrastructure that converted her manpower and economic power to military power. There is a great deal of information on recruiting, training, equipping the armies and the logistic challenges of supporting them. One note, this book is not a tactical or operational blow-by-blow account, it covers the campaign in broad strokes after explaining how the Russians developed the military power to defeat Napoleon.

The Briar Club: A Thrilling and Powerful Story of Female Friendships and Secrets by Kate Quinn was an excellent book about a Washington D.C. boarding house for white collar single women in the 1950s. The book is intricately plotted and very well written and I enjoyed it immensely.

The Eagle and the Hart: The Tragedy of Richard II and Henry IV by Helen Castor was an excellent account of the reigns of these two kings, the last Plantagenet and the First Lancastrian. The book covers both main characters, their relationship, and how two rebellions eventually transitioned the ruling house from one grandson of Edward III to another. I found it fascinating and it, along with reading a biography of Henry V earlier in the year, sparked a new interest in Medieval warfare that has had me researching, printing and painting armies and reading rules. I recommend the book.

Clown Town (Slough House Book 9) and Standing by the Wall: The Collected Slough House Novellas both by Mick Herron are much of a muchness with previous Slough House books, if you’ve read and enjoyed them, you’ll want to read these. Clown Town should probably be read in sequence, but I think new readers would be OK starting their Slough House journey with Standing by the Wall.  

When the Moon Hits Your Eye by John Scalzi was a disappointing novel that started off in absurdity, when the Moon suddenly, literally, turned into cheese. Things just progressed from there. I’m sure someone out there enjoyed it, but it wasn’t my thing.

‘Tis Herself: A Memoir by Maureen O’Hara and John Nicoletti is the memoir of one of my favorite actresses. O’Hara comes across more or less exactly like the characters she made a career playing and she provided a lot of insight into the “golden age of Hollywood”. I enjoyed the book immensely.

The Glass Hotel: A novel by Emily St. John Mandel is a convoluted, but very well written, novel from one of my favorite authors. It tells the story of the protagonist in a non-sequential way that can be a little hard to follow if you’re not paying attention. I liked it, but not as much as I did the first time, I read it.

One True Thing: A Novel by Anna Quindlen is an absolutely wonderful book about a 20 something woman who leaves her publishing career and long-term relationship in NYC to care for her dying mother at the behest of her father, whom she idolizes. As the book progresses the protagonist’s views on her mother and father change profoundly. This book was extremely well written, and I got a tremendous amount out of it.  

Pompeii: The Living City by Alex Butterworth, Ray Laurence was one of those books that attempts to make history more” accessible” by fleshing out historical records with archeological findings and a great deal of extrapolating to tell plausible stories about people that we simply don’t actually know very much about. The stories in this book are engaging, but perhaps because I’ve read too much from Dame Mary Beard, I just wasn’t confident that they were accurate. Read it if you’re interested in Pompeii or ancient Rome, it was fun, I just wasn’t confident in it.

State of Wonder: A Novel by Ann Patchett was another outstanding novel about Dr. Marina Singh, a pharmacologist who travels to the Amazon rainforest to investigate the death of her colleague who had been sent to find Dr. Annick Swenson, Singh’s former mentor, who disappeared while researching a miraculous fertility drug. Much hilarity ensues including, but not limited to, snakes, drug dealers, a cannibalistic tribe, Singh’s affair with her boss, life in the darkest Amazon, and erstwhile hippies. The book is very evocative and well plotted; I had no idea what would happen next. I enjoyed it and I recommend it.

WWII: A Chronicle of Soldiering by James Jones was a massive disappointment. In 1975, James Jones wrote the text for an oversized coffee table book featuring visual art from World War II. The book was a best seller, praised for both its images and for Jones’s text, but went out of print when it proved impossible to re-license the original artwork used in the book. This Kindle edition provides Jones’ original prose, but not the artwork. And the prose is so closely linked to the artwork that without that context it simply doesn’t provide a coherent narrative. Avoid this and see if you can find the original from a library.

The Third Man by Graham Greene is the novella that Greene wrote as a “treatment” before writing the screenplay for the magnificent 1949 Orson Welles movie. Since the two were so closely linked there are very few differences between this and the film, the only one I’m aware of is changing the first name of the American protagonist from “Rollo” in the book to “Holly” in the film. If you like the movie, you’ll probably enjoy the book.

The War of Jenkins’ Ear: The Forgotten Struggle for North and South America: 1739-1742 by Robert Gaudi was an eye-opening little book about little known war. Because I grew up in coastal Georgia, I knew about the St Simon’s Island theater of the war which culminated in a Spanish defeat at the Battle of Bloody Marsh. I did not know that the war ranged much further than that to St Augustine Florida, Havana, Venezuela, and Panama so it was quite interesting to learn about the wider context of the war I knew a bit about.

While I Was Gone by Sue Miller is a great book about a veterinarian, happily married for many years to a pastor, whose bohemian past catches up with her when a former housemate and lover shows up at her practice with a sick dog. I don’t want to say too much else, but it really was a great book!

 
The Last Word and Other Stories by Graham Greene is a collection of short stories I checked out of the library so I could read The Lieutenant Died Last. That 1940 story, about a platoon of German paratroopers descending on a small English village to prepare an invasion was the inspiration for the film “Went the Day Well?” and also inspired Jack Higgins to write “The Eagle Has Landed”. After reading “The Lieutenant…”, I checked out the other stories which were also excellent, as one might expect from Greene.

The Face on the Milk Carton by Caroline B. Cooney was a young adult novel about Janie Johnson, 15-year-old girl, who sees her face as a 3-year-old on a milk carton as “Jennie Spring” a 3-year-old kidnapped from a New Jersey mall years before. Janie and her intrepid boyfriend Reeve eventually unravel the mystery.  This book highlights one issue with reading most things on Kindle. It was pretty good for a young adult novel, but it was no great shakes as an adult novel. Because I accessed it sight unseen from an online listing, I didn’t get the contextual information such as cover art, thickness, and placement, that a physical book would have clued me into it’s being for young adults. Anyway, if you’ve got any teens in your life, they might like it.

48 for the year.

My First Five Months of Reading

May 21, 2025

Subscribe to continue reading

Subscribe to get access to the rest of this post and other subscriber-only content.

First Book Update for 2025 a Good Start to the Year

January 30, 2025

On the reading front things are picking up a bit from the end of last year. During January I’ve finished 12 books including:

The Reverse of the Medal, The Letter of Marque, The Thirteen-Gun Salute, The Nutmeg of Consolation, The Truelove, The Wine-Dark Sea, The Commodore, and The Yellow Admiral (1996) by Patrick O’Brian volumes 11 through 18 in the 21-volume set of books recounting the adventures of Royal Navy officer “Lucky” Jack Aubrey and his best friend surgeon, naturalist, and sometime spy Stephen Maturin during the Napoleonic War. This is my third or fourth time through the books since they were written in the late 90s and early 2000s and I’m just an enthralled by them this time as I was the last time I read them.

The Submarine Boys and the Spies Dodging the Sharks of the Deep by Victor G. Durham was what we would now call a YA book from 1910 that is mainly interesting as a cultural artifact. The book is about sixteen-year-old Captain Jack Benson and his two teenage pals Eph Somers, the navigator, and Hal Hastings, the engineer, together these three are the crew of apparently the most advanced submarine in the world which they are demonstrating for the US Navy. This is the fourth of eight books in the series so the story of how these fellows acquired the submarine is probably covered in previous books. The plot of the novel is simple, Jack and his pals bring the submarine down to Florida to demonstrate it’s capabilities but are waylaid by a passel of foreign evil-doers who are hell-bent on stealing the secrets of the new submarine, if not the submarine itself. There is much too-ing and fro-ing, pretty girls, skull-duggary, etc but in the end all is well and Jack and his pals proceed to their next adventure. As I say this one was mostly interesting for the glimpse into a bygone culture that it provides so I won’t be reading the other six. Hat tip to long-time friend Dan Mason for sending me a 110 year old hardback copy of the book.

The Garner Files: A Memoir by James Garner and Jon Winokur is an absolutely delightful memoir from one of my favorite actors. Garner tells the story of his life from birth through 2011 or so with the same wry, self-deprecating voice that was such a feature of his acting. The book was hugely entertaining and as a bonus included a capsule “review’ from Garner on each of his movies. If you’re a fan of Garner you’ll enjoy this book.

At War With Ourselves: My Tour of Duty in the Trump White House by H.R. McMaster is the heartbreaking story of McMaster’s time as National Security Advisor in 2017 and 2018. For anyone who followed national security issues during that period the book is pretty much exactly what you expect. It is the story of a group of men trying to stave off the worst impulses of the worst POTUS in several lifetimes, if not ever. I just can’t recommend it because it is too depressing and you already know all this stuff.

Nine Princes in Amber by Roger Zelazny is the first volume in The Amber Chronicles which I remember reading avidly in the late 1980s. Although I remember being enthralled by them back in the 80s I retained no real memories of the characters or the plot so when I saw that a new omnibus edition was available with all ten novels I checked it out of the local library to see if I needed to buy it. After reading the first book, I do not need to go any further, and can’t for the life of me remember why I liked them so much back then. I’m a little sad that something I once enjoyed is no longer a source of entertainment, but I least the library saved me the $15.

 12 for the year

First Wargame Post

January 29, 2025

Played the first two turns of my first Midgard game. It’s a pair of 300-point armies, Early Imperial Roman and ancient Briton in the first scenario from the book called Battle.

Midgard scenarios start with players each rolling 2D6, the highest total has the opportunity to challenge the other side to a single combat. The Britons won the single combat roll and challenged the Romans to single combat. Stratocumulous (brother of Crushidomnus) meets Senior Centurion Notorius Scaeva in the center of the field….

And, realizing he has bitten off more than he can chew, dies on the point of Scaeva’s gladius..

The Britons start down two reputation tokens.

After killing Stratocumulous in the pre-game challenge, Roman turn 1, the cavalry goes out inconclusively melees a unit of Briton slingers driving them back, but Odius Defecator, the cav commander takes a pellet to the forehead. In the center the Roman line of slingers and archers advance and destroy a unit of slingers with shooting.

On Briton turn 1 the chariots come out and charge the cavalry inflicting one Stamina point and forcing them back. The Briton slingers shoot and inflict a Stamina point on the Roman slingers

Roman turn 2 sees the archers advance to put the last unit of Briton slingers in their Killing Zone. Despite all three Roman missile units being engaged, the shooting is ineffective except for wounding Motahedus, youngest son of Crushidomnus.

Briton turn 2 sees the Briton warriors advance to punish the impetuous but unwary Roman archers in melee, but bad Briton dice and good Roman support dice save the day and the Romans retreat with only their pride wounded.



Here’s the table at the end of turn 2 current reputation level is Romans-10, Britons-6. Loosing Stratocumulous in the pre-game really hurt.

I’ll be back tomorrow with my first book post of the year.

Closing Out the Year

January 1, 2025

Since my last post I’ve only finished five books, which brings me to 65 for the year. This is the lowest total of any year since I began keeping track of my reading in 2008.

The last five books were The Surgeon’s Mate, The Ionian Mission, Treason’s Harbour, and The Far Side of the World, volumes 7-10 in Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey-Maturin series and Frederick Forsyth’s The Shepherd, which I read every Christmas eve. The Aubrey-Maturin books are just as good this time around as they were the first three or four times I read them over the last 20 years. I recommend them to anyone who enjoys Age of Fighting Sail books. The Shepherd is both the quintessential Christmas Ghost story and an outstanding aviation story. The movie adaptation on AppleTV+ is pretty good as well.

I would up with 65 books for the year.

Gaming wise, I’m continuing to grind away printing and painting armies for the new Midgard rules from Reisswitz Press. I’m starting with Early Imperial Roman and Ancient Briton armies and will then branch out into Vikings, Goths, Late Imperial Romans, and Saxons. Once the armies are completed, they can be used for Midgard, Infamy Infamy, and Saga. All the figures will be 3D printed and I’ve already acquired all the necessary stl files and the rule sets and supplements.

 I’m about halfway through the initial armies. For the Romans I’ve finished the command figures, the archers, the slingers, the cavalry, and one of six units of infantry. The Britons have the chariots, the slingers, the command figures, and one of nine units of infantry. Stay tuned for pictures.

 Finally, I played my first boardgame in a very long time recently. A buddy who is reading Eisenhower’s Crusade in Europe got interested in playing a D-Day/Western Europe game. So, he came over and we broke out Hexasim’s Liberty Roads. I’ve owned it for years but have only played a couple of turns at a local convention years ago. We played through the introductory Cobra scenario a couple times to learn the rules and now we’re confident we’ve figured it out and will run through Cobra one more time before starting the campaign game.

Well, that’s about it. Thanks to everyone who has read this blog over this year and all the other years and hopefully I’ll update it more frequently in the coming year.

I hope everyone has a safe and prosperous New Year!

Catching Up the Blog…Again

December 8, 2024

I’ve been awfully busy since my last update in July which means another paltry update in terms of books read compared to previous years. I’m nowhere close to 100 books for the year. Most of my time has been split between a job search and my various miniature wargaming projects but I have managed to finish another 23 books. I’ve decided to retire so hopefully I will finish the year a bit stronger. Anyway, here’s what’s been added to the finished pile since Independence Day.

Annie Bot by Sierra Greer is a pretty conventional but fairly well written story of an android designed for the sexual pleasure of its owner becoming sentient and questioning its status as a non-volitional being. I recommend it if you’re into these sorts of stories

Fourteen Days: A Collaborative Novel by Margaret Atwood, Douglas Preston et al is a gimmicky novel that came out of COVID.  The book, a collaborative effort by a slew of famous and not so famous authors, describes the denizens of an apartment building in NYC during the pandemic. Each evening the residents meet on the building’s roof at 1900 hours to bang the pots and pans to cheer on the front-line workers and enjoy a few adult beverages. Each evening more and more residents show up on the roof and each resident is written by a different author who tells that resident’s story. The book covers 14 evenings with a chapter for each. It’s an interesting and engaging book which kind of put me in mind of the Decameron. I recommend it.

The Trouble with Tycho and Cosmic Engineers by Clifford D. Simak were a pair of mostly forgettable novels from the “Golden Age of Science Fiction”, neither of which was particularly memorable.

If I Die in a Combat Zone: Box Me Up and Ship Me Home by Tim O’Brien is an outstanding memoir from one of the great literary voices to come from the Vietnam War. O’Brien describes his experience from the time he received his induction notice through bootcamp, his time in Vietnam, up to his discharge and primarily focuses on his internal thoughts and feelings. I found it tremendously interesting.

Deal Night on Union Station (EarthCent Ambassador Book 22) by E.M. Foner is the latest installment of a series about a universe with dozens of different alien species all interacting under the supervision of an extremely advanced race of benign artificially intelligent androids. The books continue to amuse me, and I recommend them for light, entertaining, reads, but start from the beginning since the books are closely related in terms of the overarching story.

Axiom’s End by Lindsey Ellis was a weird First Contact novel wherein a 20-something human female falls in with a very advanced, telepathic, alien who is attempting to save Earth from being destroyed by another group of very advanced, telepathic, aliens. The “good” alien needs the girl’s help and of course the US government “men in black” are pursuing them as well. It wasn’t a bad read.

The Silver Waterfall: How America Won the War in the Pacific at Midway by Brendan Simms and Steven McGregor was a not great book on the battle of Midway. Shattered Sword was a much better, more comprehensive book.

The Pharmacist by Rachelle Atalla is a forgettable little post-apocalyptic novel about a small population surviving some un-named catastrophe in a bunker. It was just OK.

Learning the World by Ken MacLeod is about a generational colonization ship reaching the end of its 400-year sub-light journey and finding the planet it was supposed to terraform and colonize already inhabited by sentient aliens albeit less technologically developed ones. The book mainly focuses on the internal politics of the groups involved; the aliens dealing with a potential invasion from an advanced race and the colonists who are divide into two groups about what to do about the aliens. It wasn’t bad, I recommend it for its unique perspective.

Magic Pill: The Extraordinary Benefits and Disturbing Risks of the New Weight-Loss Drugs by Johann Hari is a bit of a mixed bag. It starts with a good scientific explanation of how Mounjaro/Ozempic etc. were created and their physiological effects, but then it morphs into a kind of squishy sociological analysis and pushes changes to the food supply chain. It was just OK.

Diana Rigg: The Biography by Kathleen Tracy is an unsatisfactory biography that seems to be entirely composed of excerpts from interviews and articles. There is no evidence of any author conducted interviews or access to Dame Diana herself. Not really recommended.

A Man on the Moon: The Voyage of the Apollo Astronauts by Andrew Chaikin was an outstanding account of the entire Apollo program. Each mission is covered very thoroughly from the mission plan to the training, through the execution. It is extensively sourced and very enlightening. If you’re a fan of 1960s/70s NASA you’ll definitely want to read this book.

Leviathan Wakes, Caliban’s War, and Abbadon’s Gate by James S.A. Corey are the first three books in The Expanse series which deals with the emergence of an alien “protomolecule” and its effect on human civilization. The books are set in a future where humans are grouped into three distinct factions; Earth, Mars, and The Belt all more or less mutually antagonistic toward one another. I’ve gotten through the first three which are all excellent and I’m sure I’ll make my way through the others at some point but probably only as they become available in the library. I recommend them to pretty highly to anyone interested in classic “hard” science fiction.

Women and Power: A Manifesto by Mary Beard is a brief little book tracing misogyny, and the silencing of women’s voices all the way back to the ancient Greeks and Romans. The book is a powerful examination of how deeply ingrained misogyny is in Western Culture and anyone who is a woman or cares for women should probably read it.

Master and Commander, Post Captain, HMS Surprise, The Mauritius Command, Desolation Island and Fortunes of War by Patrick O’Brian are the first six volumes in the 21-volume set of books recounting the adventures of Royal Navy officer “Lucky” Jack Aubrey and his best friend surgeon, naturalist, and sometime spy Stephen Maturin during the Napoleonic War. This is my third or fourth time through the books since they were written in the late 90s and early 2000s and I’m just an enthralled by them this time as I was the last time I read them.

60 for the year

Catching Up The Blog

July 4, 2024

Lots has happened since my last update back in February, but not much of it has been reading. The main time sink has been a 3D print Napoleonic Army project. So far this year I’ve printed and painted approximately 1200 6mm Napoleonic figures organized into 230 bases to play a variety of Napoleonic rules sets including General d’Armee2, Et Sans Resultat, Blucher, and Volley & Bayonet. Anyway, since February I’ve finished 15 books bringing me to 37 for the year which is far off the pace to get through 100 this year. I guess we’ll see what happens during the second half of the year.

The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley was just OK. The story is that the British government has figured out time travel and brought individuals from various eras forward into the present. These people come from the ECW, Elizabethan London, the 1847 Franklin Expedition, and the British Army on the Somme in 1915, and each of them is assigned a full time, live in, “bridge” who helps them navigate the modern world and reports back to the ministry on their progress. The main characters of the novel are the RN officer brought forward from the Franklin Expedition and his female, Cambodian-British, bridge. As might be expected from the setup, romantic sparks fly. There is also a rather murky overlaying plot of conspiracy and skullduggery. It wasn’t a bad book, but it wasn’t as good as I had hoped. Get it from the library.

Nightfall and Other Stories by Isaac Asimov is a collection of Asimov’s early pulp stories and is mainly interesting as a glimpse into the beginnings of the Golden Age of science fiction. It was OK, but none of the stories really stuck with me.

Table for Two: Fictions and The Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles were both excellent! Gentleman was a re-read of an outstanding book triggered by the book being made into a mini-series on Showtime featuring Ewan McGregor as Count Alexander Rostov. Table for Two was a collection of interlocking short stories that collectively form a novel about Hollywood in the 30s featuring one of the main characters from Towles’ earlier Rules of Civility. It too was outstanding, but to get the most out of it, read Rules of Civility first.

Sharpe’s Rifles by Bernard Cornwell. I had to read this just to see what all the fuss was about among my Napoleonic wargaming friends. It was OK, not as compelling as Hornblower or the Aubrey/Maturin novels but still a fun read. I’ll read more of these, but probably only as they become available from the library.

Hunting the Falcon: Henry VIII, Anne Boleyn, and the Marriage That Shook Europe by John Guy and Julia Fox was an outstanding, exhaustive, thoroughly researched look at the relationship between Henry VIII and his second wife. The authors have diligently dug through the primary research and assembled it into a comprehensive picture of not only the relationship itself, but it’s impact on the entire European geo-political scene of the time. The book’s main strengths are its extremely detailed account of the relationship, and placing that relationship within the context of what else was going on in Europe at the time. It is thus far, my favorite book of the year.

50 Battles That Changed the World by William Weir was an interesting and valuable book covering what the author considers the 50 most important battles ranging from Marathon (490 B.C.) to the Tet Offensive (1968). Each battle has a brief account of the battle and the war it took place in and a concise explanation of why it is so important. It was generally well done and I must confess that I had never heard of a few of the battles. I recommend it if only as a sort of “survey course” to generate further interest.

The Evening and the Morning: A Novel by Ken Follett is the fourth installment in his Kingsbridge series that started with Pillars of the Earth. This one deals with the actual formation of the town of Kingsbridge way back in the 11th century and features a Saxon Earldomen marrying the daughter of a Norman count, a gifted and intrepid but common builder, and a wide variety of both good and evil clergy. It was fun to read, but won’t stick with me like Pillars.

The Last Picture Show, Texasville, Duane’s Depressed, When the Light Goes, and Rhino Ranch by Larry McMurtry are basically a multivolume exploration of the life of Duane Moore, Texas oilman, from his teenage years, through his career, life, and loves, until his death at a ripe old age. Two of the books, Duane’s Depressed and When the Light Goes particularly speak to me because of my current stage of life. But all of them are excellent and I enjoyed them immensely.

The Maisky Diaries: Red Ambassador to the Court of St James’s, 1932-1943 by Ivan Maisky, Gabriel Gorodetsky (Editor) is, as it says on the tin, the internal musings and thoughts of Stalin’s ambassador to the British before/during WWII. It was fascinating to see the interwar years and the whole appeasement period from the perspective of a Soviet diplomat. I recommend it for anyone interested in that period.

The Maps of Spotsylvania through Cold Harbor: An Atlas of the Fighting at Spotsylvania Court House and Cold Harbor, Including all Cavalry Operations by Bradley M. Gottfried was another outstanding entry in Savas Beatie’s series. For those of you not familiar with the series, these books feature a full page, full color map, on the right-hand page with a comprehensive account of the action on that particular map on the left-hand page.  When you turn the page, you get another full-page map and another full-page account of the action. Lather, rinse, repeat for (in this case) 387 pages. The books are not only an outstanding source for the battle or campaign they cover but are equally outstanding as a companion volume to whatever other poorly mapped work of military history you might be reading on its topic. For example, this volume, and its companion on the Wilderness, would be an invaluable reference while reading Gordon Rhea’s volumes on the Overland Campaign. Any reasonably serious student of the ACW needs these books.

37 for the year

The Good Start Continues Continuing

February 27, 2024

I’m still plugging away and have finished another couple of books since my last update. I’ve finished 22 books for the first two months of the year, which is on pace for 121 this year if I maintain this rate.

Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War by Malcom Gladwell is his rather strange take on the Allied bombing effort during WWII. He starts off superficially describing the rise of the strategic bombing doctrine in the US Army Air Corps between the wars, proponents of which he terms the “Bomber Mafia”, then goes on to describe it’s failure in the ETO and the PTO before finishing up by describing Curtis LeMay’s reconfiguration of the bombing effort in the Pacific using low level drops of incendiaries and the resulting utter annihilation of Japanese cities during the Spring and Summer of 1945. What makes the books strange was Gladwell’s attitude toward the bombing campaign which he seemed alternatively to both disdain and admire. I could never quite get a handle on what his actual thesis was or what the book was trying to say. Anyway, you can skip this one.

Morte d’Urban by J.F. Powers is a novel about the trials and tribulations of a very talented priest in a fictitious minor religious order in the American Midwest in the late 1950s/early 1960s. The book, which won the National Book Award for 1963, is Powers’ debut novel and is an outstanding window into one aspect of the American Catholic existence in that place and time. If you’re Catholic, or you have a deep interest in U.S. Catholicism in that era, I can’t recommend it enough. If you don’t have such an interest, there is not much for you here.   

Serenade to the Big Bird by Bert Stiles is a memoir by a B-17 co-pilot who completed a 35-mission tour with the 91st Bomb Group in the Summer and Fall of 1944. Stiles was a talented write who had published short stories in the Saturday Evening Post, Liberty, and The American magazines before the war. The writing is excellent, very evocative of time and place, and I recommend the book very highly to anyone interested in the 8th Air Force in particular or men at war in general.


The Bullets Flew Like Hail: Cutler’s Brigade at Gettysburg by James L. McLean is almost a moment-by-moment account of the battle viewed through the experiences of the men of the six regiments that comprised 2nd Brigade, 1st Division, 1st Corps, Army of the Potomac. The book is extremely informative about the small parts of the battle these troops were directly involved in, and it is exhaustively researched, but it’s not particularly well written. Honestly, I read it only because my Great, Great, Grandfather Thomas Woods, fought with one of Cutler’s regiments, the 147th NY, during the battle. If you have such an interest, this is the book for you. If not, it’s probably way too much information.

Bloom County: The Complete Digital Library Volume 1 by Berkeley Breathed is the collection of the first year, of the strip. I started reading the strip after it came out, so I missed the first couple of years. I must say, that even as a fan of the strip, the first year was a bit rocky and the strip only began to take on its familiar contours toward the end of the first year. I did enjoy seeing the beginning of something that I quite liked back in the day and I look forward to going through the other years (I purchased the complete nine volume archive for a few $$ on HumbleBundle.com). If you were a fan of Bloom Country way back in the 80s, this is for you!

Boudica: The Life of Britain’s Legendary Warrior Queen by Vanessa Collingridge was a massive, but probably unavoidable, disappointment. The problem is that we really know very little for sure about Boudica or her rebellion, and what we do know is from very short accounts in only two ancient sources, Tacitus and Cassius Dio. Once you’re read those two accounts (which don’t always agree!) you’ve got pretty much the extent of our direct knowledge about the woman. Collingridge has filled out the book by giving several chapters on the rise of the Roman Empire from the ashes of the Republic, the Roman Conquest of Britain, and a survey of how Boudica has been culturally depicted started in the Elizabethan Era when Tacitus was rediscovered. In fact, only six of the 21 chapters (9-14) of the book deal with Boudica or her rebellion the rest cover the other material I describe above. So at the end of the day, this book isn’t very satisfactory, but it’s the best we’re likely to get on the subject.

22 for the year

The Good Start Continues

February 5, 2024

I seem to be back on track reading wise having finished eight more books since early January.

Born With Teeth: A Memoir by Kate Mulgrew was an outstanding personal memoir. She doesn’t really have a whole lot to say about the craft of acting or about any of her roles, there’s very little about playing Star Trek’s first female Captain for instance. What the book does have is a very honest and introspective account of her life, especially her family life not only as a child but with her various romantic partners and her children. When she was just starting out as an actress, she had an unplanned child which she placed for adoption. Her regret for which is sort of a recurring theme of the book. She writes beautifully, maybe that’s what drew me to the book. I’m a big fan of her Star Trek character but as I said earlier, there’s not much in the book about that role. Anyway, I thoroughly enjoyed the book.

Starter Villain is John Scalzi’s latest comic sci-fi novel. In this one a down on his luck, divorced, substitute teacher suddenly finds himself the target of multiple assassination attempts. He then discovers that his uncle has died leaving him in charge of the uncle’s entire villainous empire, complete with a secret island base in the Caribbean. Much hilarity ensues as things get sorted out.

Evil for Evil (Billy Boyle #4) and Proud Sorrows (Billy Boyle #18) by James R. Benn are a couple of entries in the adventures of Ike’s nephew and everybody’s favorite SHAFE special investigator. These books are generally well plotted and consistently engaging. As a bonus they usually illuminate some obscure part of WWII. As with most series these need to be read in order.

Masters of the Air by Donald L. Miller is a very comprehensive account of the 8th Air Force’s bombing campaign against the Germans. The book is very heavy on the theory and doctrine of strategic bombing, especially the background of how the theory was developed between the wars, and how a small coterie of US Army Air Corps officers began preparing to implement it. The book also goes fairly deeply into the relationships between the very high-level officers; “Hap” Arnold, Ira Eaker, “Tooey” Spaatz, and Jimmy Doolittle of the USAAF. Readers hoping to hear more about the individual aircrew featured in the eponymous AppleTV+ series are apt to be disappointed. Although some of that material is included, it’s really not the focus of the book. See the next entry for that.

A Wing and a Prayer: The “Bloody 100th” Bomb Group of the US Eighth Air Force in Action Over Europe in World War II by Harry H. Crosby is the book that I suspect is the actual source material for the TV show. This book is a combination memoir/history of the “Bloody 100th” written by one of the only original members of the 100th to serve with it throughout the War. This is an outstanding book. Crosby is a vivid and engaging writer, and I not only thoroughly enjoyed the book, but came away with a much deeper understanding of the experiences of the aircrews of the “Mighty Eight”. I can’t recommend it highly enough.  

Twelve O’Clock High by Beirne Lay Jr. and Sy Bartlett is the source book for the 1948 Gregory Peck film. Although the book is, as usual, better than the movie, in this case it’s not a lot better. There are also several differences in the plot which make reading the book worthwhile. If you’re a fan of the movie, I recommend this book very highly.

If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin is an enlightening and depressing novel about the Black experience in New York City in the early 1970s. The book deals with a pair of young lovers, Tish and Fonny, who are just starting their life together, when Fonny is wrongly arrested on a rape charge by a racist cop he has had issues with before. The book is masterfully written, very evocative of the time and place, and does an excellent job of describing young love and the trials and tribulations of being Black in America. I recommend it highly.

16 for the year

A Strong Start

January 16, 2024

Since the beginning of the new year, I’ve already finished eight books and in a notable departure from normal practice, two of them, the D&D book and the Longstreet bio, were actual hard copies rather than eBooks read on my Kindle.

Slaying the Dragon: A Secret History of Dungeons & Dragons by Ben Riggs is exactly what it says on the tin, a comprehensive history of the groundbreaking RPG. I played D&D casually in High School, so I found the history of the game, and the detailed and comprehensive account of TSR’s development and marketing of it enthralling. Readers should note that it is heavily focused on D&D and not a larger history of TSR. I had hoped there might be some info about the TSR/SPI interaction but there wasn’t. I highly recommend the book for anyone interested in D&D.  

Flashman by George McDonald Fraser is the first book in the series about everyone’s favorite anti-hero. This is my second or third time through the series and it’s still excellent.

For those of you reading this BLOG who aren’t familiar with George McDonald Fraser’s Flashman books, they are a series of 12 historical novels using a minor character from Thomas Hughes’ Tom Brown’s Schooldays. In Hughes’ book, Flashman is a coward and bully who persecutes Tom Brown and his friends before eventually being and expelled for drunkenness.

Fraser takes up where Hugh’s left off and tells us the story of the rest of Flashman’s life. The series is based on the imaginary “memoirs” of  “General Flashman” which Fraser describes (in a preface to the first book) finding in an antique tea-chest, in a Leicestershire saleroom in 1965. As the “editor” of the papers, Fraser produced a series of historical novels describing episodes of British and American history during the 19th century.

All sorts of major and minor figures from history appear in the books, everybody from Abraham Lincoln as a young Illinois Congressman, to Bismarck, to Rajah Brooke of Borneo to Geronimo (as a young boy named One-Who-Yawns). Fraser’s research was impeccable, and the books are heavily annotated, with end notes and appendices, as Fraser pretends to “confirm” or “correct” the “memoirs”. Often these notes inform the reader that a particularly outlandish character really existed or that an unlikely event actually occurred.

The great appeal of the series comes not only from the detail of sometimes obscure historical events, but also from the character of Flashman himself. The books are told in first person narrative, as if written by Flashman, a character who openly and freely admits to being a coward, lech and poltroon. Such an “anti-hero” is very refreshing and the perspective of such a character on historical events is delightful. All in all, if you are at all a fan of historical fiction, I can’t recommend these highly enough!


The Battle of Leyte Gulf: The Last Fleet Action by H.P. Willmott is a detailed and astute analysis of the series of naval and air battles fought between the U.S. and Imperial Japanese navies during the last week of October 1944. Willmott, as might be expected from his previous works, has a lot to say about the battle and the conventional wisdom regarding it. His over-arching theme seems to be that the correlation of forces was so heavily weighted in favor of the US that Japan had no real chance of affecting the outcome of the war, or even appreciably delaying the invasion of the Philippines. For example, Willmott, looking at both sides’ Order of Battle points out that the U.S. Navy deployed more destroyers to the battle than the Japanese had carrier-based aircraft. He also rather roundly castigates Halsey over his failure to form TF 34 and takes a few swipes at the historiography of the battle (he’s not a fan of Morison’s work). Potential readers should be aware that this is not a blow-by-blow account of the battle but rather an analysis of WHY “who did what to whom” and the larger effects of battle on the rest of the war. With that being understood, I recommend the book very highly.

After finding it deeply discounted for Kindle I purchased and reread The Forever War by Joe Haldeman. Frankly, I had forgotten that the last time I read this, back in 2010, I didn’t think it had held up very well. Describing it this way:

“So, at the end of the day, we’ve got a book that touches on a bunch of themes, the future of military ops, time dilation, and how society might change, without examining any of them in a thoughtful way. Still not a bad read though.”

I’m not as negative about the book as I was last time I read it (that review is here: Bill Pilon, “Bill Pilon’s Book Blog from Atlanta, GA” #662, 9 Dec 2010 3:12 pm) but I can’t really recommend it except as a curiosity.

The next two books; A Magnificent Disaster: The Failure of Market Garden, The Arnhem Operation, September 1944 by David Bennett and Arnhem: Myth and Reality: Airborne Warfare, Air Power and the Failure of Operation Market Garden by Sebastian Ritchie came directly from watching Band of Brothers over my Thanksgiving break. Having watched Band of Brothers, I decided I needed to add some American Airborne troops to my 15mm miniature armies. But I had to order those figures from the UK (I use Forged in Battle and Peter Pig for 15mm). While waiting for them to arrive I found a US retailer that had Forged in battle British Paras, so I ordered and started painting them. Painting them got me watching a Bridge Too Far while painting, which caused me to re-read these two books. Reading these books together was illuminating. Bennett’s book basically considers Market-Garden a near run thing that could have gone differently had small issues (moving the 1st AB drop zones, making two drops per day, lighting a fire under XXX Corps) been resolved. Then Ritchie comes along and demonstrates that none of those issues were actually fixable, that Market-Garden was more or less doomed from the start.  I enjoyed both books and recommend both highly for anyone who is a student of Market-Garden.

Blood Alone (Billy Boyle book 3) by James R. Benn starts with our hero waking up with amnesia in a field hospital in Sicily with a handkerchief embroidered with a monogram L in his pocket. Almost immediately people start trying to kill him and take the handkerchief. The rest of the book slowly unfolds the story which involves Lucky Luciano, Vito Genovese, US Naval Intelligence, the Sicilian Mafia, and the Allied conquest of Sicily. If you liked the first two Billy Boyle books, you’ll like this one. If you haven’t read them, don’t start here.

Longstreet: The Confederate General Who Defied the South by Elizabeth Varon is an interesting biography of Lee’s “Old War Horse” primarily focused on Longstreet’s career AFTER the Civil War. Varon has mastered the contemporaneous primary sources does an outstanding job of describing New Orleans in the immediate post war period and Longstreet’s position in local politics and his fight for Black social and political equality. She also convincingly demonstrates that the Virginia cabal of Lost Causers led by Jubal Early didn’t start blaming Longstreet for Gettysburg until AFTER Longstreet eschewed White Supremacy and adopted the Republican party. She ascribes Longstreet’s movement from pro-slavery White supremacist to integrationist favoring Black political power and social equality to his respect for Grant and his whole-hearted acceptance of the spirit of the surrender terms of Appomattox. Finally, she wraps up rather topically by noting that despite being the 3rd most prominent and important surviving ex-Confederate there were no monuments or statues erected to Longstreet in the post-war era. She believes this was because of Longstreet’s failure to support White supremacy and sees this as proof that those statues and memorials that were erected were primarily intended to advance the cause of White Supremacy. This is a powerful book and I recommend it to anyone interested in the Civil War or Reconstruction.

8 for the year.


Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started